OMG INFLATION!!! THE SKY IS ABOUT TO FALL!!!

in #steem8 years ago (edited)

The topic of inflation came up in comments to this post, and I wanted to write something that explains how inflation works with steem. What seems to be troubling people is that the curation, and posting rewards, along with the interest earned on steem power, will cause the price of Steem to crash.

The first thing that you have to keep in mind is that Steem is not currency or money. It is a commodity like gold, tea or wheat. This is true for all cryptocurrencies. The term (as well as the use of the word 'coin' in most of them) is an unfortunate misnomer that has endured because there many situations and discussions where the distinction is mostly academic. Its unfortunate, because it has most people running in circles when they encounter a topic like inflation, where the difference between a commodity and a currency is critically important.

Inflation means an increase in the price of goods and services. When prices increase, you can buy less with your money. So inflation means higher prices and higher prices mean the money you have buys less than it used to buy.

Which is to say that inflation is something which decreases the value of money, because it dereases the amount of things you can buy with money. What you have to remember here is that Steem is a thing, not money.

How does inflation happen? Well there are a bunch of models to explain why prices increase. The classical economics, Milton Friedman explanation is that inflation happens because of an increase in money supply. This is the explanation that typically gets thrown around when people point to inflation potentially causing cryptocurrencies to lose value. In fact, the term inflation is used colloquially to mean the increase in money supply (though thats not what it means in economics or finance) Keep in mind that just about half of the professors at any economics department at any university in the country would call the classical explanation an outdated myth.

But even from a classical economics perspective, this type of inflation won't work with steem. Yes, with currency , the classical economist believes that increasing the supply ultimately decreases the value. But its more complicated that the government prints some money, then you go to the store and the shop keeper tells you "well, the money supply has doubled. So the loaf of bread that used to cost one dollar will now cost two dollars, because i denominate my prices as percentages of the total available money supply in the country"

The actual process of classical inflation is much more complicated. It goes something like an increase in the money supply means a decrease in interest rates. A decrease in interest rates means that conumers can borrow money more cheaply, and also means that they have less incentive to save. Consumers having less incentive to save and easier access to low interest credit means a greater demand for goods and services. Greater demand means less price competition at the same supply point. less price competition causes an increase in price of goods and services. None of this really applies to crypto currency. There isnt a crypto federal reserve to get the "money" into circulation by lowering the cost to obtain it.

But all this steem, won't it flood the market? Thats not really inflation, but regardless the short answer is no. This newly created steem is denominated in steem power, which means that it can only get to the market incrementally.

Also, the supply of every cryptocurrency increases. Every single day, $1 million worth of new bitcoin is made (and before the halving, it was $2million). Whats causing misgivings here isn't the fact that new "money" is being minted, its that we can see it happening at the bottom of posts and in out steem power balance.

Sort:  

Excellent post! SP is the controlling feature here. This makes the platform valuable in a sense that people understand you need SP to maximize rewards. So, it stays in the system.

Being new to the whole Blockchain and Crypto world and what turns the wheels, i can tell you that just reading this: https://steemit.com/steem/@sigmajin/not-like-the-others-why-steem-price-hasn-t-come-close-to-peaking ..... and also this post i have learnt an incredible amount of information. ..Thankyou indeed.

very welcome.. glad you enjoyed it

Nice article. Keep them coming :)

Every three years the total number of steem is reverse split 10:1 which takes care of any and all inflation.

Care to expand on that? Sorry

It, and the reasoning behind it is discussed on page 39 of the steem white paper.

https://steem.io/SteemWhitePaper.pdf

My understanding steem accounts are created with free credit of steem power, and it will take two year to withdraw. I am wonder steem see over supply at this time. Causing steem price to crash.

Withdrawals occur slowly every week over that 2 year period. You get your steem in equal instalments. It doesnt happen all at once after the two years.

Steem idea of limit steempower conversion to less than 1% per week is a brilliant idea, coin supply will be always under control

I think that these conversations and examples will serve to strengthen the platform. Very well written. Also, it's refreshing to see people being decent with one another.

This is all theory without data. I would like to see some network analysis on the growth of the Steemit network and determine the ratio of network growth to the "minting" rate. Until this research is done, nobody can say for certain about the significance level of the inflation.

Im pretty sure "economics" is latin for "all theory without data". Here's a joke for you:

A physicist, a chemist and an economist are stranded on an island with no food. Days pass, and theyre all starving. Then, one day several cans of food wash up on shore. However, they can't get the cans open.

he chemist says "Wait!!! Ive got an idea. Well get some of this seawater, then evaporate the water off until the remaining water has a super high salinity. That will be able to eat away at the top of the cans until theyre so degraded well be able to get them open easily within a day or two"

The physicist says "Wait!!! Ive got an even better idea!!! Well start a fire, and ill melt some sand into glass and fashion a lens. With that, well be able to focus the sunlight to melt through the cans and get them open in a few hours."
Then the economist says "Wait!!! I've got an even better idea!!!! I can get the cans open right now"
The other two are duly excited "what is it, what is it?" they ask
The economist says "OK... assume a can opener...."

Haha, I actually studied economics. There are a lot of cool ideas in economics, but I'm also very critical of the study itself. Sometimes economists use too much bad data and treat human behavior like physics, which is a bad assumption. I think the way to move forward in economics is through analyzing social and economic networks rather than theorizing about supply and demand curves.

I agree. I guess my point here is that everyone who is predicting a crash is just basically yelling "money supply! inflation!", because those are well-known concepts. THere might, in fact, be a crash. But if there is, it wont be because of inflation, because thats not really appliable to something like a cryptocurrency.

Please take a look at my post here. I want as many smart people to see it as possible so that we can arrive at an objective and honest assessment about what is actually going on.
https://steemit.com/socialnetwork/@limitless/important-questions-about-the-network-effect-of-steemit

Great explanation. If you want to see a fresh picture of all the crypto currencies, take a look at https://steemit.com/steem/@brun/all-cryptocurrencies-in-one-visualization-look-there-is-steem. There it is, Steem.

Steem is inflating. I do not believe this is correct. But if the demand of steem increases, it can negate this effect. If there are 300 dollars in a market and then someone says, "I think I will give 3,000 dollars into the market" Well that original 300 dollars no longer has the same purchasing power as the 3,000 dollars . This means that your purchasing power is diminishing. If you are trying to cure debt or other problems which causes governments to print more money you see hyper inflation because the more the print the less they can use it for.
Here is a snippet from Merriam-Webster defining inflation: " a continuing rise in the general price level usually attributed to an increase in the volume of money and credit relative to available goods and services" Now you may say, well this applies to money, not a commodity like you are claiming steem is. Would you say that steem is used as a medium of exchange? Would you claim it as a raw material or something you consume? If you believe that you are holding onto a commodity would make me believe that money is a commodity. What is the difference? There are both used as a medium of exchange between their communities. By the way if you don't believe that is how one should define currency take a look at this snippet from Investopedia, "What is a 'Commodity'
A commodity is a basic good used in commerce that is interchangeable with other commodities of the same type. Commodities are most often used as inputs in the production of other goods or services. The quality of a given commodity may differ slightly, but it is essentially uniform across producers. When they are traded on an exchange, commodities must also meet specified minimum standards, also known as a basis grade." and here is a snippet from Investopedia, "Some currencies, like cryptocurrencies​, bitcoin​, dogecoin​ and other online currencies and branded currencies are not tied to any country. Branded currencies, like airline and credit card points, or in-game credits are valued in relationship to the value of the products or services they’re tied to. Control over digital currencies is entirely decentralized, and the exchange rate of a digital currency can vary widely in a short period of time. "

You're falling into a mental trap called a faulty syllogism. Steem (like most "cryptocurrencies") has several similarities to money. Its transferable. It holds value. Because it has these similarities, you assume it must be money. Youre just as incorrect as if you would be if you assumed that fido was a cat because he had 4 legs, fur, a wet nose and a tail.

So lets think about it. IS steem used as a medium of exchange? What can i exchange steem for, except the bitcoin that i used to buy it in the first place. Nothing at all.

So lets take the dictionary defnition of inflation that youre using. It makes intuitive sense. If more people with more money are bidding on the same amount of goods and services, it makes sense that those goods and services would fetch a higher price.

But steem is not used to buy goods and services. It can be sold for bitcoin (and ultimately cash in most cases) which can be used to buy goods and services, but it isnt really exchanged directly for those goods and services.

A great (and very similar) example is gold. An increase in the supply of gold has not, generally, caused an increase in the price of other goods in relation to it and a subsequent devaluation. Why? because its not traded directly against a wide basket of goods and services.

In order for the model you present to work, in order for the relative availablitiy of cryptocurrency to goods and services to effect the price, those things must be traded directly. That happens with money. It does not happen (at least not yet) with crypto of any sort. Even bitcoin, for the most part if i want to buy something with bitcoin, I either cash it in or maybe use gyft.

But once i involve that intermediary, the thing i am buying is no longer trading against the crypto. Its trading against the actual money i use to make the purchase.

So because steem is not a medium of exchange you argue that it cannot be a currency then. Well if bitcoin can be used to buy something, exchange with and trade to other people would that make it a currency? Keep in mind when bitcoin started you couldn't do anything with it. It was a milestone in the history of cryptocurrency when it was used to buy a pizza. Would that mean before that it was a commodity but now it is a medium of exchange?

Because bitcoin can do these things, can it be considered a currency? No, because it can't do them alone.

The price of the things youre buying with BTC are, for the most part, denominated in dollars or euros or whatever-- in an actual currency. So, for example. Lets say Cryptic Pizza charges a dollar for a slice of pizza, but they allow you to pay in bitcoin. There is no "bitcoin price" there is a set dollar price for bitcoins and a set dollar price for pizza. The exchange of two things are mediated by the dollar, even though dollars are never actually exchanged. The ability to do this -- to set valuations for two independent things in order to mediate their exchange, is what makes a dollar currency.
In the very same way, i might arrange to pay for my pizza with $1 worth of pepperoni. That does not make pepperoni a currency. The reason for this is that the owner of cryptic pizza has to pay for rent, gas, electric, dough, cheese etc with dollars, not with bitcoins..

The owner of cryptric pizza has to charge enough to cover his expenses and make a profit. And, for the most part, he can only pay those expenses in dollars.

This is because it is not possible to exchange bitcoin for a wide enough basket of goods for it to actually have an independent valuation against something like a pizza.

Now, you might be asking, is it possible for bitcoin to become a currency, once its gained wide enough adoption. Sure. currency evolves from commodity. But in order for that to happen, it has to gain much broader marketplace acceptance.

Incidentally, one might argue that in the very narrow marketplace of altcoin trading, bitcoin is, in fact a currency.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.14
JST 0.030
BTC 62900.39
ETH 3357.78
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.47