@smooth: Replying here due to nesting.

I mentioned the memes because the comment we're discussing says the "memes are entirely appropriate". I disagree.

I suspect it's kushed because:

1. He was the first to upvote the comments from the sock puppets.
2. The opinions expressed are in line with what I'd expect from him and the aforementioned clique.

My saying this has nothing to do with his record as a witness. I did try to look at it following your comment though and it's not as well-documented as you imply.