You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Latest Curation Reward Solution
All fundamental changes to bring things in line with the intent/vision should bemade as soon as possible. Better now, while still in beta than later when you would piss people off.
It's probably too late to not piss anyone off.
Some insist on the point that a retroactive change would be bad, and would be pissed off when it happens.
I expected the algorithm to be adapted to reach the intended wide distribution on July 4th, and would be pissed off if that huge pot ends up in a few hands mostly.
Difficult decision for our young community...
The 'wide distribution' is achieved with a combination of content rewards as well as curation rewards. Both come from the reward fund mechanism and both will be distributed on July 4 so it makes no sense to focus narrowly only only the curation reward, unless the intent is to make the distribution appear narrower than it actually is. The curation portion has always been defined as both a benefit of owning SP and a superlinear benefit. Indeed in the short- to medium-term it is the only such benefit to SP (aside from upvoting your own posts, which does no good if everyone does it). As such it should come as no surprise that the largest SP holders receive the lastest share of the portion of the reward fund that is designed to go to largest SP holders.
From what I have seen of the content rewards they are being distributed very widely to a large variety of different types of users. The primary exception there are the Steemit insiders, who gain a disproportionate share due to what I consider a glitch (possibly temporary) in the way the reward algorithm handles the small user base.
I don't see that much value in curation, voting is something most users do anyway. While I certainly spent 6+ hours a day here spreading votes the last weeks, even my old payout seemed way too high for me regarding the value I think it has for the platform compared to authors. And I'm completely opposed to derive the value of SteemPower from how easy it is to accumulate it.
I'm afraid we won't find a consensus on that issue, but at least we know each other's expectations and reasons pretty well now :/