You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: The Reasons Why Kids Shouldn't Watch Harry Potter

in #psychology7 years ago

You know, I used to think exactly like you about kids fairy tales. Until I realized that if all kids stories were void of any trace of violence and "unethical" subliminal messages like the ones you mentioned above, they would all have to be similar and this is called ...censorship.

I personally read many stories as a kid with what I later realized were terrible messages to pass on to a kid. Cinderella was a poor girl who pretended to be someone else in order to become a trophy wife. Hansel and Gretel burned someone alive in the oven for revenge. My favorite book was "The Blondie" (it was from my native country) and displayed what I now understand as pure racism. The whole story revolved around how pure and kind was the blond fair-skinned girl and how evil her dark sisters (the darkest, the meanest).

As a kid I was also exposed to a lot of violence while being taught nationalistic stories about physical tortures of national heroes. Let alone some traditional songs that came up with some very creative ways to die.

Yet I'm here now and I believe that all this exposure was something that aided me in becoming a freethinker. A protective bubble isn't the answer. If you are not exposed to something, you cannot know what it is about and therefore you cannot fight it. Initially, one has to be exposed to a diverse range of ideas. This is what will eventually create contradicting concepts in one's mind, which will force the individual to examine them more closely. The key word here is diverse. If you only read a genre, or articles from a specific school of thought... you will never know what the other side has to say.

Sort:  

Thanks for the response :-)
It has nothing to do with protective bubble, really. There is no mentioning of censorship or banning. Only criticism and suggestion why this movie is psychologically detrimental propaganda.
Banning or censoring anything is an infinite patchwork that never solves social problems andd focuses on effects.
If we want to solve social ailments we must focus on reshaping social conditions in its roots - focusing on causes not effects.

About "free" thinking. If we become open minded and cognitively less biased is caused by mixture of many deterministic and random events that have happened throughout our lives. Simply, we are lucky to have developed ability for "free" thinking. Especially in this society which does not support it. You may think that these fairy tales contributed to your certain cognitive ability but there may be completely different experiences that contributed to it. You may be one between thousands of kids who read those same fairy tales or more and they have not helped them to develop more individual way of thinking like you.

Also, kids cannot really fight something and they don't have very developed ability for critical and analytical thinking. They are also emotionally immature so they are very sensitive to any indoctrination by media, adverts, movies, entertainment, books etc. It is adult caregivers role to protect them from it. It has nothing to do with being in the bubble. When those kids grow up a bit they are free to explore other information.

About "free" thinking. If we become open minded and cognitively less biased is caused by mixture of many deterministic and random events that have happened throughout our lives. Simply, we are lucky to have developed ability for "free" thinking. Especially in this society which does not support it.

I totally agree with you on this one. And my exposure on these stories certainly does not mean that they were what caused me to develop a more individual way of thinking. This is actually a very good point.

Personally, I was exposed to many different (intellectual) stimuli while growing up. Which is why I think that its a very helpful practice to teach children how to think for themselves. Most parents tend to hide certain realities from their children- they avoid talking openly about death, sex, religion and other sensitive subjects. My parents were open about all subjects and I was allowed to read books and watch movies about any topic.

Kids who are exposed to these stories are not necessarily improving their critical analysis skills, but kids who are exposed to a wide range of ideologies including these are very likely to, as there will come a point where one concept defies the other. The human mind mainly works with comparisons, thus the more reference points, the broader the perspective.

Interesting point about referencing information.

You had very cool parents who seem to be great role models for you.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.18
TRX 0.16
JST 0.029
BTC 62324.87
ETH 2419.55
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.65