Do We All Have a Capacity for Evil?
We are all familiar with the story of Lord of the flies. During a time of war, plain evacuating a group of English boys get's shot over a tropical island. Pilot dies, while many of the children survive and find themselves stranded on an uninhabited island.
They begin by establishing a society similar to the one they left at home. They start hunting for food, making shelter and developing a civilization in order to survive. But soon this civilization starts degenerating. Different clans are formed ruled by fear and violence and by the end of the book several boys have been killed.
William Golding wrote this book shortly after the World War II, so his pessimism about society was understandable. The world still felt atrocities of the Holocaust, atomic bombs and other horrors of war.
Is Golding's view of the world distorted or does everyone has innate ability to do evil?
One of the best known psychological experiments in history dealt with this topic of how humans react when put in various social situations. In 1971, A group of Stanford researchers led by professor Philip Zimbardo put 24 undergraduates under the microscope.
They arranged improvised prison in the basement of Stanford building, took these students (without criminal record and considered psychologically healthy) and made them act as guards and prisoners. They randomly assigned half to be guards and half to be prisoners. Researchers then observed behavior of the prisoners who had to stay in their cells 24/7, and the guards who took 8 hour shifts.
The experiment was designed to last for two weeks, but had to be stopped after only six days due to extremely abusive behavior of guards towards prisoners. On the first couple of days nothing happened, so they even thought of quitting the experiment because it looked boring. But from there, prisoners started demanding the freedom, and the guards looked at them more as a dangerous prisoners than as students. Tortures and aggression escalated so they were putting bags over their heads, stripping them naked and making them participate in extremely humiliating sexual activities. Psychological torture put prisoners under huge amount of stress and anxiety.
Professor had to stop the research after it got out of control to the point where he feared that consequences could be tragic.
What if it is true that every living creature has a capacity for evil, whether or not he acknowledges it? Maybe we all have the potential of doing cruel, immoral actions when in extreme situations. Or the better question may be, does the goodness in people overcomes the bad situation, or does the bad situation overwhelms the good in people.
The Stanford research and several similar experiments lead to the troubling conclusion. When put in tough situations, it's not that difficult to get people who were considered normal to act shockingly bad. As human beings we have both good and bad characteristics and abilities, and what separates normal people from the "psychopaths" is their ability to control negative urges, to resist acting them out.
Throughout history, humans showed they are willing to do anything to feel safe, secure and attain position of power. A sense of conscience and personal accountability is what keeps us from doing wrong.
Maybe that's why in the movies, books or tv shows we often better relate to gray characters who have good and bad in them than to pure paladins. Even the heroes that appeared noble and good had their hearts easily corrupted or filled with greed. Cause we all have capacity for heroism and selfishness. It's just the question of which one overpowers the other.
Like in the native American legend, old Cherokee is telling his grandson about the fight between two wolfs that's happening inside each of us. One wolf is anger, greed, arrogance, while the other is kindness, hope, love. When asked which wolf will win, he simply replies with "the one you feed".
Hope you liked this! If you do, don't forget to upvote and resteem it. Also make sure to follow @alcibiades to stay updated about future posts .
Hello @alcibiades,
Congratulations! Your post has been chosen by the communities of SteemTrail as one of our top picks today.
Also, as a selection for being a top pick today, you have been awarded a TRAIL token for your participation on our innovative platform...STEEM.
Please visit SteemTrail to get instructions on how to claim your TRAIL token today.
If you wish to learn more about receiving additional TRAIL tokens and SteemTrail, stop by and chat with us.
Happy TRAIL!
I have a pretty pessimistic look on humanity. All around us are examples of greed. I read an interesting article a while ago, saying we do good to make ourselves feel good. To justify us living in wealth while others do not. I don't think this counts for all people, but I did think they made an interesting point.
People definitely have capacity for evil. Mostly fulled by greed and self preservation. I'm just so sad to see so much evil that doesn't seem to fit that 'logic'. Like how youth now feels the need to terrorize others to have a good time. Filming how they beat up innocent people. Intimidating people walking by. Look at all the stuff on television making fun of other people hurting (translated to funniest home video-like programs).
Is it all escalating, or is it just that we see more of it because of tv and internet?
I think it's both. It's much more visible now with all the media, but that itself promotes even more of it. People are selfish and greedy by nature, and different situations only bring that to the surface.
Thanks for the excellent input!
Another example
A Clockwork Orange
Excellent example! A Clockwork Orange shows attraction to evil as a natural part of humans. Just as natural as good.
glad to help
We all have these wolves in us. Circumstances around us tend to dictate which one rises above the others. It's human nature. I guess most people lack the will to do good or have simply refused to acknowledge it.
Well put. It's much easier to do evil. And more spectacular, I guess. It takes strength to be kind.
What's "evil?" is very much a contextual thing. If you killed someone - it's an evil act. But if you are a soldier and killed many enemy soldiers - you are a hero.
This post has been ranked within the top 80 most undervalued posts in the second half of Jan 08. We estimate that this post is undervalued by $5.14 as compared to a scenario in which every voter had an equal say.
See the full rankings and details in The Daily Tribune: Jan 08 - Part II. You can also read about some of our methodology, data analysis and technical details in our initial post.
If you are the author and would prefer not to receive these comments, simply reply "Stop" to this comment.