Free speech. My thoughts, and some observations
I don't think in the UK we have truly grasped the whole concept of free speech, not all of us anyway. I know I sit amongst an entire community of people that defend the vulnerable and fight for life’s injustices that I'm quite right in my observations when I say that we're slightly lacking when it comes to the concept of speaking your mind. I know because most of free speech hurts. When people throw free speech in our faces it's usually because they are touting for something that can be controversial to some.
My backstory
Let me give a little of my background. I've worked in the voluntary sector for most of my life. Throughout that time, I've had to learn the words that offend and the phrases that can start controversy in certain groups. I've learned how not to isolate and I've been taught how to include everyone regardless of their stance on anything; I had a perfectly normal discussion once with a man that thought hanging should be brought back. Most importantly, I've learned not to judge people so critically anymore, and this comes from a place of better understanding; the narcissist can be the way that they are because of an extreme childhood at home. Not that I'm defending their actions but I do sit from a place of understanding it.
I'm beginning to wonder if this is the right way to go though? I agree, there are certain members of society that shouldn't be open to such avenues of potential of abuse because of their vulnerabilities, but I'm also certain that doesn't mean they never should be exposed to it. Let's be clear here, some of the best lessons I've learned in life is when I have been dragged through the mud kicking and screaming. I learned not to bully others in School when the kids brother that I was bullying came and rearranged my face. I learned not to play women off one another very early on in life when they eventually ganged up on me, made my life intolerable and rendered my dating life in the community almost optionless. I learned not to get flat out drunk and pass out in the bar when my clothes were taken off me and I had to run back home naked, and most importantly I learned not to piss off people that help me. I'd have never learned any of these very tough lessons if I hadn't been given the chance to experience them.
Differing opinions
The same can be said for freedom of speech. Freedom of speech is harmful in some cases, yes, but then doesn't it allow you to know that the sort of opinions and ideas that you disagree with exist? I say that from an attitude that I'd rather know my enemy than be taken out of the game when I thought life was at its most comfortable, usurped by my very real false sense of security and ignorance? That's what we have been growing in Britain. A slow but steady train of thought that everyone exists happily together through a wondrous eclectic community of diversity and acceptance. Yet since 2010 I slowly realised that I had been duped. I was very proud that my nation was one of the world’s forward thinking leader in freedom of speech, diversity and acceptance of culture. It turned out that wasn't the case at all.
For years there has existed and undercurrent of increasingly angry people. Bitter that they haven't been allowed to express their feelings, and even more hurt that it was not a popular thing to do. Pre-2010 it was definitely not acceptable to speak racially. Since then, and since it has become far more acceptable to speak out about division and race, the rise of UKIP and Brexit, we have saw the underbelly of toxic Britain rise up and spew forth its bile and hatred ontowards anyone not within normal cultural parameters of a perceived 'Briton'. In my mind, it would have been so much better if we had allowed them the freedom of speech. There wouldn't be this stark undercurrent of people that feel their needs aren't being addressed. I for one know what happens if you suppress a human. To allow freedom of speech is to allow yourself the option of knowing what the other opinions are out there.
Americans be crazy, yo
I remember the first time I joined an American debating group and was fucking shocked at some of the inhumane and crazy conversations that were going on in there. People outwardly talking about the genocide of n*ggers, killing Atheists / Bible worshippers and so on. Some of the conversations that I was witness to wanted me to put my fist through the screen at the gross injustices of humanity. After some time though I began to realise that I had been made aware that this existed, and that was good. I am more than sure that there are vast swathes of people that think exactly the same way in the UK but keep it behind closed doors because of our systems in place. I really, really, really didn't agree with what they were saying but I was glad that I was finally aware that a lot of people believed this stuff. There's a lot to be said about knowing the different side of the coin.
In a sort of masochistic way, I admire America for that right. For bringing us extreme hate groups like The Westboro Baptist Church. Could you just imagine the damage they could have done behind closed doors? The fear and hatred they could have indoctrinated our youngsters were they not in the public eye? An example of course, and from what I had observed the Westboro Baptist Church had its kicks from being in the limelight. I doubt at all their message was important, only a bunch of attention junkies hopped up on the media spotlight they were given. Still, the notion remains. People achieve much more in the shadows than in the limelight. An idea spreads faster than wildfire when not in the public domain. And this is why I am quite proud of Americas open speech policy and their people that like to be loud and in your face.
Free speech travels both ways
Let us never forget though that freedom of speech is a concept that both parties should be signed up for. It is so that you can tout your bullshit to me and I can equally refute it, or vice versa. I had a friend that I went to school with get really angry with me because I was always refuting his rather extreme views of immigration whenever I decided to have a Political discussion on my Facebook. I was always met with chants of I don't like Freedom of Speech and I'm only holding my leftist stance because it's popular, yet what he failed to realise that I did not shut him down nor disallow him from posting. He could say whatever he wanted to me whenever he had the time. Freedom of speech is clearly everyone having their say regardless if we agree or not.
Personally, I think we have a lot to learn in the UK. We have had Brexit; where many of us laughed and jested that a situation was not possible because there just wasn't enough people who oppose immigration or dislike Europe. Yet, in complete assassin style those that had been once silenced and now had the options to vote with their heart, to which they did, and rocked Britain to the core. I'm no Brexiteer but I understand why it happened. People have been angry for years. People have been shunned, ignored, minimised and not listened to. They weren't allowed to voice their opinions. And thus, Brexit happened.
Echo chambers of fragility
And this is why I say freedom of speech is a good thing. It allows us the opportunities to speak our minds and oppose the injustices of the world whichever way we believe. It gives us the awareness of what’s out there rather than sitting in our own little echo chambers of fragility, not accepting anything else but the sniffing of our own farts (think South Park haha).
Thanks for listening! I'd love to hear your thoughts?
Awesomely described. The trend nowadays dictates that honesty and straightforwardness are to be sacrificed to diplomacy and pretentiousness.
It always starts with good intentions. Racism must be stopped, right? Sexism must be stopped. Equal opportunities for everyone. Everyone deserves love!
...It always ends up oppressing people the same way it condemns, because it is being imposed. Freedom of speech is the worst form of oppression, since just like you said, any form of expression can be equally refuted.
Restricting freedom of speech means that:
That pretty much sums it up!
I just followed you. That was so well described I think I'll enjoy your content
Thank you. I've followed you too. You are very good at writing!
Thank you. I'm getting better at it :)
Good post @raymondspeaks ...free speech to most politicians is great when the speech is on their favor..however when its against their favor, then they will do eveything in their power to term the preson a criminal or discredit the person in any inhumane way possible. I salute those brave people who stand their ground-against all odds. Thanks for sharing
@raymondspeaks Definitly! Free speech is the most important thing No doubt. Humanity needs to embrace the idea of daring to speak freely! Nice article :)
Good point @armano...great
Agree. And, thank you :)
you are welcome..great guy
Thank you!
Free speech will always be in opposition to fascism. While fascism has been defined in the past by right-wing authoritarian control, I believe that fascist behaviors are bi-partisan and not specific to one type of ideology.
I think the issue is more of a personal one. The type of people who want to assert control over other people, these kinds of people are not specific to a certain partisanship, and threaten the freedom of speech. I think it's a problem of behavior. How these feelings manifest though, there are too many circumstances to tell. There is a part of human nature to succumb to group think and be cynical of opposing viewpoints due to cognitive dissonance and other psychological perspectives.
This is exactly it. Bang. Spot on. It's not a matter of Political idea it's a matter of behaviour. Realistically, everything is.
Britain is weak on free speech. It's the main reason I'm glad today my ancestors left the island. Yeah, I like people over here speaking their mind, yo.
It's very much weak on free speech. I hadn't realised until I began to follow Americans
While I fully support "free speech", I also loath stupid/unintelligent speech. Seems there must be a happy medium? Paging Aristotle . . .
I agree. I don't enjoy unintelligent conversation which is why I try to keep out of it :)
Agreed, but sometimes I realize it when it's already too late . . .
That's very true also! Guilty as charged!
Yep, it should never grant that ability
I agree with you that keeping a radical group in the shadows can foster an atmosphere that is dangerous. Having the Westboro Baptist Church out in the open allows the public to judge their ideology on it's merits and can be discarded if one likes. Without free speech you end up with controlled speech. At that point, who is the arbiter of what you're allowed to say.
Yep, so very true! Controlled speech scares me
In Norway some leftist politicians have been rambling on about "speech-responsibility" uhhh..there's no such thing mister. It's just free speech. Sure, you can't threat people, but you can say pretty much whatever. Some people are starting to argue; "it should be illegal to hurt someones feelings" What?? That is very dangerous indeed to begin going down that path. Feelings must be hurt!
speech-responsibility is a great idea but you'd need the whole country to be on the same, happy level as you. No-one is. There are people, like me once, that had to tolerate loud music by a group of Romanians at 3am in the upstairs room. I don't mind immigration because I understand human behaviour but that sort of 3am music is likely to wind the shits up even the nicest of people.
Well..that is just normal common decency not to play music at 3 am.. With speech-responsibility, in my opinion, they are pissing on all the ideas that made the west so great. It was because of free speech we got rid of the patriarchy (yes it's gone, even though some scandinavian feminist - and as it seems even more american and europeans too, are talking about this undecipherable institutionalized racist and woman demeaning system, which no one really can point at anything close to a fact..but still claim it exist) , oppressive churches/religion and how we learned to tolerate each other (for the most time). Some leftists are extremely backwards - the are so progressive they become regressive. When they ask for speech-responsibility, what they are asking about is to take away my right to offend you. They want offensive stuff to be illegal. Can you imagine the totalitarian implications that suggests? If my meanings are offensive to you, you can charge me with a crime on the basis that you got butthurt. :) That is some ISIS shit right there just in a snowflake political correct disguise.
You make a good point there. I think people should be a bit more open minded to being butthurt. Like I say, being butthurt is a part of life. It helps you grow as a person
Thanks. Yes, it does :)
It's great to here how the life lessons you've learned shaped you in to who you are. Great comparison between life lessons and freedom of speech
Thanks! Really glad you spotted that. I'm one for letting people learn by their mistakes rather than wrapping them up in cotton wool
Free Speech is like you said... harmful or liberating... but it is necessary in both cases to get solved sort situations and speak up our minds the only thing is that there are not enough listeners...
As a diplomat of sorts in the past this is so very true. Both ends need to state their stances for a solution to present itself