New on here, and just discovering posts, so maybe a bit late. But that is a hard decision. I like both alot (no, not too helpful). They evoke such different feelings. Almost a joy vs. ...pensive, somber?? The boats in yellow/blue are so dramatic, and really shine through in color. But I've always liked B&W... usually evokes such a fine art feel, particularly with lots of details. Different medium for different subject/intent? Guess I've pretty well muddied up that picture for now : )