RE: Sittin' Up with the Dead Blog - Post 016 - Loophole Four - The Nuclear Option
I'm really loving this series, Stan.
Todays's episode brings up the question of people who commit heinous crimes because "God told me to do it".
How do you, in your mind, differentiate between God telling Abraham (as one example - but I could also have used a number of mass slaughters perpetrated by the invading Israelis into the Promised Land)
and, say, the mother who drowns her children in the bathtub because "God told her to" (I am too lazy to look up the reference but can assure you that it was an actual reported event in your country. In my own country we had a psychotic travelling in a bus decapitate a fellow passenger on "God's" instructions.
Getting down to the personal, I do not support any national or international level of government - but not on the "God told me to do it" level of justification but because they offend my conscience and critical thinking by their claims vs actions. I consider myself to be a Sovereign Individual that may delegate some of my sovereignty, at my discretion, to those I so choose (not those chosen for me). My allegiance is only to my own conscience directing my critical thinking - which is probably how I communicate or come into harmony with what you may be calling "God".
Thanks for the encouragement!
The issue you raise is the main problem with anyone who claims that they have a direct communication from God. God has indeed done that from time to time, but I sense that overt commands are very rare (although subtle hints are continuous). The overwhelmingly more likely case is that negative "voices" one is hearing in one's head are coming from one's own thoughts -- or someone much more sinister.
Of course, my standard answer is that true inspiration from God will never contradict His existing Scripture. (And refusing a suggestion based on quoting that conflicting Scripture is always a pretty safe bet.)
Matthew 4 shows how Jesus used Scripture to deal with such a "voice". Anyone rejecting what is written in Scripture is basically adrift with no concrete way to sort out who said what in that never ending 3-way "chat thread" we all have in our minds.