Patents - the real story of the most evil creation of govern-cement.
Patents, the biggest waste of time, energy and resources an inventor can do.
Whenever an inventor talks to anyone about their ideas, that other person invariably tells them they should get a patent. I know that these people are usually caring and genuinely desire to help. But, in reality, what they recommended is pure evil.
The beginning of Don Lancaster's infamous article about the realities of The US patent system. The Case Against Patents |
The best description of a patent is that it is a $5,000 gun, but the bullets cost a million dollars a piece.
A large corporation doesn't care about your patent. They will not buy it. They will not honor it. They would rather spend $100,000 busting your patent than $10,000 to buy it. And bust your patent they will. Or they will do something even worse, they will drag your court case out for decades. Or they will do something even worse than that, they will counter sue for all of their lost profits due to your filing a false patent case.
Full document here
And little guys don't care about patents either. The not atypical story is that an inventor gets a great idea, patents it and starts building it. His neighbor sees it, thinks that's great, and starts manufacturing them too. The inventor goes to court to stop the neighbor. He wins after much time and money. The copy-cat files bankruptcy. The inventor doesn't get a dime. And the copy-cat moves across the street and starts manufacturing again. At this point the inventor is back to square one. He has to go start the entire court process over.
The medium sized guy who is actually in the business of producing legitimate products is the only ones who really care about patents. And they care from a stand point of being afraid of having patents used against them. They are in a position of losing a lot of time and money because of some lawyer suing them. If they win, they lose a lot of money. If they lose, their entire company will be destroyed. And these people are trying to be legit and on the up and up.
Back to the little inventor. Unless the product you have invented is going to produce more than a million dollars in net profit, it isn't worth getting a patent. But, there is all kinds of other things that you can do that are actually far superior.
One thing is to file the patent (It costs $500) and write on your product Pat. Pend. Which everyone takes to mean patent pending, but actually it is meaningless. And if you have filed the patent, whether it is approved or not, you are legally covered. Of course, you are never going to court over the product, because you know that the products life span is short. So, once you got this product selling, you are already working on another.
Another thing to do is to fully publish your invention. Don Lancaster recommended writing a magazine article telling everyone how to build it themselves. Which usually ended up with the inventor actually getting more job offers than they could shake a stick at.
An offshoot that occurred today on Steemit.com is that you can publish it on steemit. Steemit being an immutable block chain can verify to any court that you had prior work (what you need to defend against a patent law suit). What used to be for inventors a lot of jumping through hoops (getting your document certified by a notary and then mail it to themselves for an affirmed date), is now as easy as pushing post on steemit.
All ideas are not really our own. Ideas come into this planet and are heard by several people (who are listening) at the same time. The Wright Brothers took their first powered flight only two weeks before a Frenchman did. So, don't by into the hype about trying to keep your idea secret. In an actual business, the product is only the tip of the iceberg. Marketing, distribution and cash flow are far more important. Besides, competition is not bad, it actually helps a lot. If you have a brand new product that no one has ever heard of, you have to go through a lot of effort to get people to know that it exists. 3M almost failed with sticky notes, until they did a national ad campaign about how to use them. So, don't be afraid to get them out there.
But, if you are still really afraid of anyone knowing about it, you can post it, and then immediately edit it to be something else. It will still be on the block chain, but you will have to be specific in going and finding it, using a tool like steemd.
So, be bold in this new era of thought creation. And use steemit as a way to publish prior work to save you from any future patent hassles. And stay away from The US patent system. It is really one of the most evil inventions of the thing we call govern-cement.
Patents are really a horrible idea, it literally grants a monopoly to somebody for inventing crucial technology that could have been invented 10 minutes later by somebody else.
People say that patents are needed since how else will people innovate and spend money on R & D if not for a government enforced guarantee of monopoly?
I call bullshit on that one. Money can be crowdfunded, research can be delegated. It's no big deal.
You already have prime examples of this with Dash & Monero, all R & D is community funded. No need for patents there.
You literally have scumbags trying to patent blockchain tech that was invented for the public good already.
So it's really a horrible idea most IP it is. Although I am undecided about trademarks. The rest of them are stupid, even copyright.
Couldn't agree more.
I looked in detail at a hypothetical scenario, pointing out just some of the ways one could profit from an invention without recourse to public or even private IP protection.
(Past payout)
Yes, exactly so. If we could stamp out that phrase "you should patent it", that would be real nice.
pending...
Nice gif.
please upvote me, i will upvote https://steemit.com/steemit/@parmjit/diy-rotating-led-clock-kit
I check out people's posts who have made an interesting comment on one of mine.
I also read through the NEW tab often.
I vote for what I like.
begging for votes here will just piss people off.
whereas this article I can get behind 100%
well, thought out, well argumented and well written pretty much
I think that everything these days is thought of to be a banquet for the lawyers and a minefield for the rest of us
should have listened to those who told me to become a lawyer
it's just wordplay after all.
Good thing you didn't. Becoming a lawyer destroys your soul.
The first half of law school is about law. The second half is how to lie (legally speaking)
Then you have to give up your The US citizenship.
Thanks for your reply
that second part is easy, no US citizenship here to give up.
If I had it I would renounce it.
and yes, I could not have been a lawyer, that's for sure
If I had done I would have renounced it too
thanks mate
big hugs
The beauty of Blockchain! First come - first serve.
We can hash-proof anything on the blockchain.
As for patents - I was not even aware until this well written/researched article.
It is when we look for govenement to protect us. Uhuh! The system is rigged. Governments do not create value - they usurp it.
The concept in this post describes the real value creator - and we don't need gov or lawyers to 'protect' us...
Loved the post!
Thank you much. I hope to have more along this line. Because, going forward, patents and copyrights won't be enforceable. You can't crack down on a video, when everyone has a video sharing server.
Especially liked the concept of : Ideas/inspirations coming to us, collectively - a few are listening, even fewer are acting on it.
Looking forward to future posts...
Too bad this post is not giving me an option to resteem, the advice about posting an idea on Steemit and then editing to hide it is not bad at all.
Yep, the post is already months old. I am really slow on getting things written and drawn. But, that's another story...
I am running up against the term open-source...
and its cult like following, but what I usually find is people wanting money, to do some experiments, and then, after that, they will give up their findings to the world.
And often, these are things I could write up in a day. Because they have already been done.
So, I am non-plussed with open-source. I think people should put it on steemit.