You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: @Helpie Witness - Preliminary HF21 Position
Pretty much entirely agree with your analysis.
I'm very under informed wrt SPS. Is the 'burn' proposal always going to be there by default just like the 'return to treasury' proposal? Or do people have to make one each time? I guess we could propose to have an auto burn proposal if it doesn't come with one, but just wondering if it does.
Also, do you have the roughest guideline as to when you think it's a better idea to start voting for 'burn' rather than 'return'? Or do we completely play this by ear?
It has to be done manually by the stakeholders. So it could be a little awkward. And you'd have to make one with just the right amounts I suppose. Nothing is automatic, but I do remember hearing the 'return to treasury' will be one of the first ones to go up.
No guidelines about burn vs return. I figure always returning gives the highest flexibility to in terms of funding, however it's also very awkward in that if you continue to return everything, the proposal to return needs to scale with the amount of funds in the treasury until they are ready to start disbursement, or just set the number to an unreasonably high number to keep it returning funds until others are ready to be voted above.
yes, I sort of share those minor concerns/uncertainty. But shrug, I guess they're relatively minor
Oops. I meant to respond to this as myself. But ah well, either way :)