Protectionism: When it should and shouldn’t be applied and the option of a Sliding TariffsteemCreated with Sketch.

in #money8 years ago

Alt Text
Protectionism: When it should and shouldn’t be applied and the option of a Sliding Tariff.

International trade can be a contentious subject for discussion depending on what side of the fence you are on. On one side, there are employees losing domestic jobs to international competitors and their cheaper imports. On the other, when trade protections are created, the US buyer ends up paying the price in terms of higher prices for items which are artificially inflated to accommodate the tariffs.
For good reasons, certain key industries must always be protected from international competition. The US must protect itself from Chinese dumping cheap steel into the American market because the US steel industry must still be production ready say if a war were to happen. If all steel were to be imported supplies might be cut off from the US market when it is needed most, for tanks and armament etc.
Another example of tariffs protecting a strategic domestic market is Japan and the rice trade. Rice is considered a staple to the Japanese diet and rice farmers are considered an asset which must be protected if external food supplies were to be cut off.
Tariffs can and must be applied to strategic industries and products, but they need to be applied judiciously. When tariffs are applied as blanket policies such as the newly mentioned 20% import tariff on all Mexican imports it only hurts the future economic development of domestic industry by providing a quick fix against economic competition and it hurts the US consumer by artificially inflating prices for the good that the tariff affects.
For the most part, companies in the private sector withstand regular and natural economic tides (ie. layoffs, downsizing, re-gearing the workforce for greater efficiencies and company expansions) Without these natural economic struggles companies become weak and complacent. Workers and management does not seek greater efficiencies which are needed to compete and the failure of the company a whole becomes a greater possibility.
But what should we do in the case of a non-critical industry which is suffering because another country dumping cheap imports into the domestic market? When tariffs are applied, they become very difficult to remove since the industry receiving the benefit will lobby to continue the subsidy well after the threat from cheap imports is over. The solution might be to apply a sort of Sliding Tariff which is in full affect when cheap imports are being dumped and peter off if the quantity of the dump diminishes on a yearly basis.

Just food for thought.
Please upvote if up like the article. All proceeds go to SteemPower :-)
Cheers and Keep Steeming!!!
Alex Gomez

Picture provided by: " http//:europe.chinadaily.com.cn/opinion/images/attachement/png/site1/20160809/f8bc126d98201913682808.png"

Sort:  

The rare earth magnet industry was such a key industry.
Well, if The U.S. needs them for their missile guidance systems... well, the entire industry went to china. Sorry, the cronies only protect their own industries.

The import/export is so fucked up, that you need to contract a company specializing in it to get your goods.

This sliding tariff will not work. The politicians couldn't tell when something is being dumped until long after all the damage has happened. And then they will rush in to cause more harm.

I don't know what Chumps plans are, but I do know that most of the stuff made in mexico that is imported to The U.S. is made by what used to be amaerican owned companies, making stuff specifically for america.

Yes. I think that China controlled over 90% of the world market for rare earth metals a few years ago. I don't see the media addressing the issue any longer. I wonder if that situation created a rush to find new sources.

You might be right. I could see politicians and lobbyists bickering for years on the whether the tariff should be slid forward or back. Then they would collude to game the system for more profits.

everybody just needs a little rothbard..

LOL. If he was still alive I'm sure he would have a secure cabinet position now.
Thank you for commenting

Cheers :) and following you gratz on making it to the trending page and me being there ;D . Anyway back on topic, tarifs would only hurt the economies , or at least I think so, as far as I've heard Mexico has had a boom and have been growing quite large in manufacturing and industry and on the other hand America has been constantly loosing jobs businesses and manufacturing, sure they have a great services market and probably the best economical traders and such, technology and all , but in their case having no base and losing their workers constantly isn't a good deal.

Anyway I'm not much into politics and haven't been up to speed with the Trump so far, I've heard of his 100 day plan I'm interested to see what he does and how it goes , but after watching the debates I'm strongly uninterested :D

Thank you for commenting!!! The US has lost many manufacturing jobs to Mexico over the last few decades. The theory is that lo cost manufacturing jobs are OK to lose as higher tech manufacturing can stay in the US but somehow I don't see that happening. If Ford builds a $10B factory in Mexico which still needs factory workers, I doubt they would have any incentive to move it back to US when it gets updated to mostly automated manufacturing. They could just retrain a few locals to maintain the high end robotic equipment instead of moving the whole factory back to the US.

I'm hoping for the best with the new administration but I have to agree that the debates didn't give me much hope either. LOL

Each arm costs thousands and weighs tons, so yeah no moving there :D , Americans are getting the short end of the stick , a stable middle class is a basis for society :) Robots and Speculators can't cut it :|

I'm also hoping America gets to solve some of their problems rather than just put them off and pile more on top, sure will be hard to get through that stinky pile in such a short while , no wonder everybody hates Trump :D

the longer version 36:34
BMW USA Factory Tour

And how about that megafactory from Tesla :) , have you heard about that :)

Yes. After so many years of failed attempts at electric cars its nice to see an American success story. The new Tesla Gigafactory is huge and it looks like they might be able to generate their own power with turbines and solar panels. Very impressive.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.15
JST 0.028
BTC 61940.19
ETH 2433.78
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.50