You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Steemit INTERVIEW: @teamsteem talks starting on Steem, Communities, veganism,

in #life6 years ago

Plants do not have a brain, nervous system, or anything else to suggest that they have the capacity to feel pain or suffer. If you stab a carrot, apple or grain of rice (for example) it will not react or attempt to avoid the knife in any way. I've not seen any reliable source of information to suggest that any plants commonly eaten by humans have sentience or can feel pain. If you have seen something that proves otherwise I would be interested to read it.

Even if such evidence exists, it is still not a valid argument against veganism anyway, because livestock actually consumes far more food than it produces. If you really cared about the "feelings" of plants it would still make sense to go vegan, since so many of them are grown just to become animal feed. Going plant based would equal less plants being consumed overall than with an omnivorous diet.

Sort:  

external stimuli does not = sentience.

Just like our immune system reacting to a foreign substance isn't done consciously, plants having chemical reaction to stimuli doesn't equate to them being sentient.

Exactly, Siri and Alexa also react to external stimuli but nobody is suggesting they are sentient!

"But before he could even get a match, the polygraph registered an intense reaction on the part of the Dracaena. To Backster, the implication was as indisputable as it was unbelievable. Not only had the plant demonstrated fear — it had also read his mind."

Source: https://www.nytimes.com/news/the-lives-they-lived/2013/12/21/cleve-backster/

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.21
TRX 0.14
JST 0.030
BTC 69500.15
ETH 3394.50
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.75