Is Steem facing an Existential crisis or are we just Paranoid?

in OCD5 years ago

image.png

In the short time that I have been on Steem, I have encountered a few changes and problems that the community has got together to tackle. Some of the issues were minor and only required making small alterations to the code while others required wholesale changes.

The recent acquisition of Steemit by @justinsunsteemit represents the greatest existential threat the community has ever faced and Sun's silence, coupled with rumours of a move to "move the Steem Blockchain to Tron's network" has led to widespread paranoia that spiralled into the recent Softfork.

I chose to be cautiously optimistic about the Tron and Steemit union. In recent times, it has mostly been beneficial to the community as a whole, with lots of new members coming through from Tron network. The 'cautious" part of the optimism was the off chance that Sun had intentions of actually "onboarding" Steem to Tron. I can't wrap my head around the techy side of that statement, but considering how often it was talked about in Spam blogs and websites, there might be some truth about the rumour.


paranoia

The paranoia spread a bit further when news about @justinsunsteemit strongarming the witnesses in Tron Network through the use of ninjamined stake and considering Steemit is the flagship Application of Steemit network, it wasn't out of the question to hold similar suspicion.

For those without a tech background, Ninjamined stakes are derived in the initial stage of a blockchain's development. They are gotten through announcing a coin without any prior warning or buildup and mining it then. Steemit Inc. is the pioneer dapp, and they have a shit ton of those stakes that could technically be used to veto decision-making like say moving the community to Tron Network for example, through backing their witnesses with the said stakes that is presumably way more than we probably know.

Now here's where things start to become interesting; remember that paranoia I talked about earlier? Yeah, it seeped into the other witness that presumably have the good of the community at heart to secretly conduct a Soft Fork that @therealwolf describes as a Protective Soft Fork.

The statement read(mine has a few minor grammatical corrections but retains the crux);

Today, on the 23rd February of 2020 at 10 PM UTC, the majority of Steem witnesses have accepted a temporary soft fork (v0.22.2), which immediately prohibits certain operations from Steemit Inc-owned accounts.
This software update is temporary, reversible and no other accounts have and will be affected.

In other words, "Listen @justinsunsteemit and @steemit, we're shitting bricks, and we're going to need you to say something" and well, the whining finally got to @justinsun's ears. This led him to release an open letter to the community, where he said a couple of nice things about the community and then scheduled a town hall meeting with every stakeholder on the 6th of March. I'm hoping he'll tell us not to worry about the rumours but if they are correct and then he'll let us know how far up our asses he intends to screw us.

As much as the witnesses I gave my vote to have mine and the community's interest at heart, I find it concerning that they made such a big decision in secret. I also think it is somewhat ironic that the top witnesses could make a "secret" decision because @justinsunsteemit and @steemit may also be plotting something in secret. Something that hasn't actually been confirmed by anyone.

I'm not trying to play Devil's advocate. Far from that and for what it's worth, I think it is a good move by the top witnesses to curtail the activities of Steemit Inc. until we get a clear view of their plans. That notwithstanding, I also question making a move out of paranoia and unfounded fears.

For all I know, @justinsunsteemit is a businessman, and the only thing that matters to him is making a profit, hopefully not at the expense of the community. So we wait to see how things go, and I'll be keeping my fingers crossed for some good news.



Sort:  

I think leaks might have been the concern which led to being secret.

The question of paranoid is valid. I dont think we will even know the answer to that.

Posted via Steemleo

We just have to watch and see I guess

Thanks for this great vision & thoughts Damn:), "paranoia" might see promising & want to get the detaila of all that it entails! Witnesses stands for our faith in the whole of this Steem partnering with Tron, & @steemitjustinsun should bring decisions that are cogent to work well with Steemit Inc. Thanks for all that share with us here.

It's something we have to watch and see how it unfolds

I know that the community always wants to be kept "in the know" when it comes to witness decisions, but I can also respect that we ask them to do a lot - and sometimes it does need to be done in secret.

The problem I have with the secret here - is that I don't think many of the community really believe that this was done for our protection.

It protected something!!!! But I think its obvious that with Justin's stake being able to COMPLETELY rearrange the top 20 witnesses - they were most likely concerned about protecting something ELSE first. Their rankings.

"This software update is temporary, reversible and no other accounts have and will be affected."

Doesn't it just make you want to throw around that phrase that's becoming spawned everywhere.... #fornow LOL

That's what everyone is most concerned about. If they can do this to him - they can do this to anyone. You just have to create a reason, and voila. Done.

Will they do that? That's not the point. The point is this sets a very dangerous precedent. One that shows they put their own fear before what was protecting the integrity of the chain.

And now we wait and see. That response from Justin was pretty nice. (for now LOL)

But once his money is back.... hmmmm. Then we will see.

17 of the top 20 witnesses are powering down. I wonder why? More witnesses disable their witness in the last few days. Makes you wonder what is not only on the horizon for Justin -but for a lot of witnesses too.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.15
JST 0.030
BTC 65353.52
ETH 2654.64
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.84