Oh man! This will be a long and deep discussion where we will probably end up agreeing to disagree, but I will love it anyway, as you seem to be one of the brightest minds I have yet came across and I enjoy discussing interesting subjects with intelligent people. :)
I'll make my argument in a proper article and call that to your attention. It will be too long for a comment and I believe others may profit from additional exposure to this our conversation. It will happen later today, as now, I have to go check out a patient, but you won't go unanswered.

Maybe we should create a philosohers community. lol