John B. Calhoun on Population, Behavior, and the Future of Humanity
Humanity is obsessed with the end of the world. Will the world end with a bang like a meteor, asteroid, volcano, or bombs? Will it end with robots and AI taking over? Will it end with a deadly and infectious bioweapon? All of these are possible, but I think it's just as likely it will end in a whimper.
I gave ChatGPT 18 articles and books to read from John B. Calhoun on his studies on population. This is what the AI summarizes for the future of humanity:
Overview
This document synthesizes the key insights, experimental findings, and long-range predictions of ethologist John B. Calhoun across his published works from 1962 to 1993. It is designed to teach a reader unfamiliar with Calhoun's work how his theories of behavior under crowding relate to possible trajectories of human society—especially in regard to population dynamics, role differentiation, and extinction risk.
Core Experiments and Findings
Mouse Utopias and the "Behavioral Sink"
In his famous Universe 25 and other habitats, Calhoun provided food, water, and shelter in abundance but constrained space.
Populations of mice would initially thrive, but once they reached 4–6 times optimum density, dramatic social collapse ensued:
Breakdown of maternal care
Withdrawal from social roles
Sexual deviancy or complete cessation of mating
Rise of aggressive, passive, or autistic behaviors
"All members lost capacity to sustain or develop effective relationships with both their physical and social environments." — 1987, Population Extinction from Crowding-Induced Universal Autism
Social Role Failure
As young mice matured, they were unable to find meaningful social roles, leading either to violent outbursts or total withdrawal.
The "Beautiful Ones"—groomed, healthy-looking mice—exhibited no mating, no curiosity, and no social behavior. They represented a terminal phenotype of social meaninglessness:
“They did not mate; not mating, there were no conceptions and the population eventually became extinct.” — 1976, Toward a Social Stress Theory
Key Concepts
Behavioral Sink – collapse into repetitive, pathological behaviors under crowding.
Social Velocity – capacity to move through physical, social, and conceptual space.
Universal Autism – species-wide breakdown in cognitive and social functioning.
Predictions and Human Implications
A 200-Year Transition (1975–2175)
“Starting ca. 1976 the world population of humans began to enter a 200-year transition... from long- term increasing phase to a longer, but slower, decreasing phase.” — 1987
This marks a shift from biological expansion to either evolution or collapse.
Three Paths for the Future (1972)
From Revolution, Tribalism, and the Cheshire Cat:
Revolution / Neoevolution
Technologically enhanced individuals
Decline in total population
Role enrichment and expansion of social velocity
Supported by environments fostering personal complexity, adaptability, and cooperative potential
This path emphasizes smaller, intentional societies with flexible role distribution and high ideomass.
Tribalism
Population stabilization
Ritualized but stagnant culture
Loss of innovation and individual differentiation
Here, cohesion is maintained through tradition, but roles become rigid, creativity fades, and cultural dynamism declines.
Senescence / Collapse (The Cheshire Cat)
Continued population growth (up to 50 billion by 2200)
Cultural and cognitive degradation
Eventual extinction
As crowding intensifies, individuals lose ability to engage in meaningful roles. Society mirrors Calhoun’s dying utopias: functioning outwardly, but empty of creativity, responsibility, or reproduction.
“Species pathology comparable to that of the mice” would result if crowding analogues persist in human society. — 1987
Quantitative Forecasts
Projected global population by ~2060 (1972 projections):
9.0 billion – if growth continues
7.5 billion – if population stabilizes
6.2 billion – if proactive reduction begins
By 2200:
Unchecked growth could reach ~50 billion, leading to collapse and extinction.
Designing for Survival
Calhoun’s work emphasized that survival depends less on resource abundance than on designing environments that sustain meaning, cooperation, and role differentiation.
Group Size Optimum (N0)
For rats and humans, the optimal group size (N0) for stability is ~12 adults.
Within such a group, members can maintain identities, roles, and stable relationships.
Once groups exceed 4 × N0 (~48), only about 8% retain fully functional roles.
Cooperative Environments and Role Expansion
In Universe 35, Calhoun tested habitats where food could only be accessed cooperatively (e.g., two rats pressing a mechanism together).
These systems:
Fostered interdependence
Reduced isolation
Encouraged purposeful interaction
They echoed human societies where mutual aid and intergenerational support underpin resilience.
Ideomass and Social Complexity
Ideomass: total density of meaningfully differentiated behavior in a system.
Healthy societies foster ideomass through variety, creativity, and fluid role movement.
Pathological ones collapse into repetitive or empty behaviors.
Calhoun stressed that space is not only physical, but social and conceptual. Overcrowding’s true crisis lies in the inhibition of self-actualization.
Biological, Psychological, and Cultural Lessons
Crowding Doesn’t Just Cause Stress—It Blocks Growth
Removes opportunities for identity, exploration, and adaptation.
Young lose access to mentors, niches, and unoccupied roles.
Leads to arrested development, stalled cognition, and juvenile fixation.
The Collapse Is Cultural Before It’s Numerical
Populations may remain large while functionally extinct.
Signs include:
Breakdown of parenting and courtship
Withdrawal from collective life
Emotional detachment, loss of trust, absence of long-term goals
Lack of creativity and curiosity
The Breakdown of Conceptual Space
Crowding limits capacity to think abstractly, imagine futures, or plan alternatives.
Societies regress into shallow, repetitive interactions.
Extinction occurs not when no one is born, but when no one can imagine why they would want to be.
Calhoun’s Legacy
John B. Calhoun’s research remains foundational to behavioral ecology, urban psychology, and social systems theory. His cautionary tales, told through mice, illuminate possible futures of civilization.
His enduring question:
Can a species survive its own success?
The challenge he leaves us is clear: design not for growth, but for meaning, cooperation, and evolutionary self-awareness.
Find more at JeffThinks.com or JeffreyAlexanderMartin.com