If you liked the The Witch (2015) then you are surly going to enjoy Oculus (2013). An even more similar film would be The Wailing (2016) which became one of the biggest hits ever in Korea. It got 99% on Rotten Tomatoes. Some things will be lost in the cultural context. o you might have to do a bit of extra research on the movie too.
I just watched the Oculus and The Wailing trailers. I will add them to the list, I like to watch "alternative" films occasionally, especially when the film has a reputation that precedes it.