I'm a fail as I chose #1. I do like the black on you and the short dress really accentuated those boots, which really worked well with the dress. You are tiny and the layers were nice, although I thought the sleeker look was fabulous on you.
Oh, my two cents wasn't worth even that! LOL
!tip
Awh thank you for the extensive comment @dswigle! Usually, I would prefer a black dress as well. Maybe that's why I went for the grey one, just to try something different.
And thank you so much for the tip, that's very generous of you!