You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Ethical ramifications of, The PRIME-DIRECTIVE

in #ethics5 years ago

To have principles is to be under obligation and responsibility. The 18th century Westphalian philosophy of "sovereign" nation served a specific purpose within a context of ending the Thirty Year's War and limiting imperial power. The modern world has no emperors or singular superpower to dictate universal policies. The modern world lives by moral relativism, which you champion, under which all national actions are beyond reproach, even "violation of sovereignty."

The premise of "sovereignty" is based upon the assumption that nations have some "right" to exist. Nation-states are arbitrary creations of 19th and 20th century political convenience. Nations have no "right" to exist. If you believe in the "rights" of nations to exist, then why aren't you demanding the reconstitution of the USSR, the Ottoman Sultanate, or the Austro-Hungarian empire? Nations have "sovereignty" over the regions they can project authority. Syria is no more than areas around cities to which Assad can project power. Since the 'Muricans can project fair degree of power across large swaths of the globe, the areas under which 'Murica can project power are its "sovereign" territories.

It is the same with "personal" rights. From whence do men imagine they derive their "rights" to exist? In a world, in which there exists no principles, no man can claim any "rights" that which he can not personally wrest from the clutches another.

Sort:  

The modern world lives by moral relativism, which you champion, under which all national actions are beyond reproach, even "violation of sovereignty."

Have fun burning your own STRAW-MAN.

I believe in ONE SET OF RULES FOR EVERYONE.

I just put PERSONAL PRIVACY (sovereignty) at the very top of that list.

What's at the top of your list?

Do you have a list, or do you just make up your "objective morality" on-the-fly?

Let's compare notes, I'll bet you we probably agree on more than you think.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.13
JST 0.027
BTC 59239.80
ETH 2662.03
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.48