Understanding Tolerances in Engineering

in #engineering9 years ago (edited)

gears-1236578_1920.jpg

Why in the hell doesn't this fit properly? All they needed is to make it the exact same size as the other one!

When designing or manufacturing something, different kinds of technical drawings are usually used. The shapes and sizes are determined by the drawing, even though there is a small detail which causes some issues:

You can never manufacture something in an exact size


It might sound odd, but you just can't. Ever tried to cut something to an exact length? Got it right? By what accuracy, you might have tools which have 1mm accuracy but.. what about 0.001mm?
That's really small and you might think it doesn't even matter. It may matter.

A tolerance is what we call the limits of acceptable difference in size, length, distance etc., I might have designed an object with a hole. The hole may be drawn to have a diameter of 5 mm, but with a tolerance that it can be 0.2 mm smaller or larger.
Now imagine the hole is designed for a rod, 5 mm of diameter. It might have similar size tolerance, 0.2 mm smaller or larger. Sounds good, right?

Still having fun?

Now let's imagine how the object is manufactured. The hole is within the tolerances, 4.87 mm of diameter. Within the tolerance.

However this time, the rod happens to be 5.15 mm of diameter.

It is within the tolerances.. but now we have difference in size. You can't fit a bigger rod into a smaller hole without causing some damage unless you use special methods of attaching the rod to hole, like heating up the area around the hole to cause it to expand and to be able to enter the rod.

However this will lead to the situation where the rod will be stuck in whatever position it was attached to the hole in.

400px-Mechanical_Tolerance_Definitions.svg.png
Wikipedia Commons

This is why we need to work on the tolerances

There are plenty of different tolerances and they have strong standards, at least ISO standards are commonly used. However you can find all of these in Google, so it's no point of adding all the tables in the post. The tables are usually something like this

There are three different types of fits with tolerances. But I've been taught that it can be simplified into two: Either to make a big enough clearance that everything fits together easy and maybe give a possibility for the objects to move.

For example, you might have a hole to have a tolerance of +0.1 to +0.2mm and the rod has tolerance of -0.0 to -0.3mm. Thus always when both are within the tolerances, the hole will be larger than the rod. Yay!

The other way is that there is pressure. The tolerances are designed to give slight or great hold, meaning different kinds of removable plugs (which require some strength to remove) or stronger fits, which cause the materials to permanently stick together.

In some of these cases, thermal expansion is used to attach the items to each other. You heat up the other one and/or cool down the other one. When the temperature difference normalizes, the items will be attached to each other.

This is quite often seen when adding bearings to a axle.

This is just a very light touch in tolerances

There are tolerances in shape (no round object is 100% round etc.) or in other things, like surface roughness. Even in size tolerances there is much I have not touched, but I tried to keep this.. interesting?

Meh, good luck with that.

bearing-2314582_1280.jpg
This and first picture from Pixabay!

Sort:  

This reminds me of my father who was a machinist, telling me how he would have to explain to the noobs who would come into the shop and start talking about exact and perfect. He would then have to refer them to the first chapter of the machinists handbook regarding how exact simply does not exist. All you have are closer tolerances limited by your machining tools and measuring devices.

Oh I can imagine he might have got a lot of people asking for exact or perfect :)

It's odd how we have an idea of perfection, which can actually never be met. If we find something "exactly" something, it is because we don't have enough accuracy in our measuring tools.

Just like I also enjoy baking and in some guides, it is mentioned that it has to he exactly of certain weight. Luckily everything has succeeded even if there are few grams of too much butter or sugar.

Calling @originalworks :)
img credz: pixabay.com
Nice, you got a 4.0% @minnowbooster upgoat, thanks to @apsu
Want a boost? Minnowbooster's got your back!

The @OriginalWorks bot has determined this post by @apsu to be original material and upvoted(2%) it!

ezgif.com-resize.gif

To call @OriginalWorks, simply reply to any post with @originalworks or !originalworks in your message!

I honestly barely under stood this but i do hate whrn things dont fit!!

It's ok, I'm pretending to be smarter than I actually am by making sure not everybody understands this :)

Perhaps you can come and explain things to the ppl who run the train that im currently on....

Well if you get them to pay me I can come and check it out!

@apsu!!!

Are you a mind reader? My recent post ALSO talks about tolerances, but for image editing. The thing I expressed when explaining them was to try to get as close as possible without overshooting.

There is some insight in your post, measurements are never "exact/perfect", but to come close. In machinery and engineering I could imagine how impactful understanding tolerances are :000

I am! Or what if we are soulmates?

Or even better, we are the same person with a mental disorder? ;)

They seem to be using tolerances in so many things, meaning a bit different but still pretty much the same. But I'll have to admit something..
I didn't want to brag in the post, but nobody else than me can make perfect, as I'm the only one able to do that.

You others have to use tolerances.

Not a bad mental disorder to have!~ :D

Yeah, as I was reading through I was like woah, I kinda get it- time to take up engineering ;0 since we are technically the same person, Imma let it slide this time.

Bruh I need more tolerance!

Not a bad one, however it'd be nice to know which one of us is the real one?

Well I do recommend choosing engineering, as you already know the tolerances, so the rest is pretty much easy.

If I would be growing animal called tole, I could have a tole-racnh!

Lol we are both real, unless you are truly bread! Going to stick with CIS, engineering is a lot of math D:

What would a tole look like??

CIS engineer is someone who is born engineer in an engineer body.

However many people are trans-engineers, as they didn't born in an engineer body but have been engineers on the inside.

I'll have to tell you, my engineering hasn't been a lot of math :D

Tole would look like... something between a cow, goat and alpaca. Big, soft and horns pointing up. Droopy ears though. Short snout.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.05
TRX 0.32
JST 0.082
BTC 65845.39
ETH 1771.23
USDT 1.00
SBD 0.44