Educational Alternatives to Animal Dissection

in education •  last year

Taking the life of an animal to learn anatomy is more expensive, but not more educational, than several alternatives.

dissectiontools.jpgDissection tools (credit: Retama)

An education in biological sciences usually entails animal dissections. Throughout my own studies I have seen frogs, sheep brains, cow hearts, rats, and fetal pigs in the classroom. Yet under closer investigation, the practice of dissection might not be as useful as it is prevalent.

Mixed Attitudes


Much of the protest around animal dissection centers around the ethics of taking an life for educational purposes. For example, fetal pigs used in laboratory settings have an unsavory origin: they are removed from the uteruses of pigs that are killed for meat while they are pregnant. While attitudes towards dissection are not particularly well studied, existing research in students across educational levels show prevalent uneasiness about dissection ethics, and tend to strongly support the right to opt-out of the practice. In fact, laws in many states (including mine) protect students' rights to opt-out of educational dissections without being penalized.

Effective Alternatives


The efficacy of alternatives to animal dissections in education has been demonstrated in many studies. An experiment in 2003 involving ~102 undergraduates showed that students who modeled organs from clay scored significantly higher on both low and high difficulty anatomy questions than students who dissected cats. In 2007, a systematic review of dissection alternatives determined that “in all 17 studies reviewed, results associated with the alternative method of instruction were not significantly different from or superior to results associated with the conventional method.” These studies are reflective of a growing body of literature suggesting that most dissection alternatives are just as effective, if not more effective, than dissections themselves. Furthermore, these alternatives are often substantially cheaper than the dissections themselves.

ratdissectionDissection of a pregnant rat in a biology class (credit: Allen Lew)

Dissections in Your Class


The viability of dissection alternatives was not something taught in my biology classes. In my most recent course that involved dissections, I only became aware of an alternative to lab dissection after finding a short note at the end of a lab manual chapter. I wish that my school better explored alternatives, and that the student's right to opt-out were taught in the classroom. After all, revisiting the efficacy and morality of common practices is in itself an educational opportunity. If you want your school to better explore dissection alternatives, contact your teachers today!

Thanks for reading!

follow_somethingburger.gif

This post is CC BY 4.0

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Yes. More can be learned by the debate than by the dissection.

Haven't schools reached the technology level of using videos yet?
I bet we can dissect a large variety of animals and film them from every angle, then send a copy to every school or even student with a fraction of the cost and killing.
we have 3D videos now, why are schools stuck in stone ages I can't understand.

·

Good point, this is another cheap and viable alternative!

Edit: sorry about the double comment, steemit is lagging...

Interesting and thought provoking @somethingburger... are 3D printable organs an option for this sort of study? 3D printing might offer detail and varying textures where clay might now... could be an interesting option one day soon.

·

This would be an incredibly awesome future. But as of right now, it would be much more expensive! This makes a good point: alternatives will improve in both educational value and price as technology develops.

Congratulations @somethingburger! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of upvotes

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

By upvoting this notification, you can help all Steemit users. Learn how here!

Congratulations @somethingburger! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of upvotes

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

By upvoting this notification, you can help all Steemit users. Learn how here!