Cultural Appropriation, and why we should do more of it.

in #culture6 years ago (edited)

During a process called growing up, I appropriated all manner of lessons, traditions and hand signals, culture of all kinds, into my brain. I didn't just learn from my parents but from everyone I could catch a glimpse of. I learned from my grandparents, I learned from the TV, I learned from summer camp and from many other sources.

Then, later in life, the world started to tell me that cultural appropriation is wrong. But without cultural appropriation, I would still have the brain of a baby.

baby-brain.jpg
Finding images on mobile sucks

In 2009 I moved to Colombia and immediately started appropriating their culture. The first thing I tried to do was change every bit of my culture (English) that came out of my mouth and replace it with the local culture (Spanish). Even with many years of Spanish classes, it took me a long time to satisfactorily replace English with Spanish, although I have been given much credit throughout the years for trying.

I quickly got a job as well, and one thing that my boss emphasized to me was that under no circumstances was I to appropriate the Colombian culture around time; though time is relative in Colombian culture I was to treat it as absolute, if I wanted to work at this place I would have to keep my US culture regarding punctuality. I was instructed to appropriate the language and the food but not the time!

centaur-3189763_1280.png
Some sort of Hybrid Creature

At one point in my life I read the Bible. I then checked my moral compass against what I had read in the book. My very favorite book is Proverbs, I read it quite often even today. You might say that I have appropriated many of the lessons from Proverbs into my life. I am not Jewish nor a descendant of the King Solomon, but I have appropriated the lessons he wrote for his children.

I also walk around with a machete tied around my waist. I find that I need a machete at least a dozen times a day, so I just hang it there in the morning. I learned this from the Colombians, when in Colombia, do as the Colombians do. But when I go to Bogotá, I leave my machete behind, respecting the Colombian law that no machetes be carried in the city.

chanklamachete.jpg
Machete with Flip-flops, only before coffee

Relativism or Absolutism: The Moral of the Story

Within philosophical discussions you can sometimes hear mention to moral relativism and moral absolutism. These are different ways of viewing morality. I'll give you an example.

An absolutist would say that murder is wrong but killing is okay (provided some definitions). A relativist would say that this justification of killing but not murder is proof that taking life is relative, sometimes okay and sometimes not. This is a deep philosophical discussion that has gone on among humans for thousands of years.

descarga (1).jpeg
Relative Absolutes

So here I am, a Spanish speaking, Proverbs following punctual machete carrier, who uses his American wiles to post all about these appropriated adventures on the Steem blockchain, when somebody says, 'Cultural Appropriation in Wrong!'

Now, those who want us to stop appropriating the cultures of others are generally moral relativists, meaning there is most likely some set of circumstances in which it is okay to appropriate, such as language in a new country. In fact, just being in a new country might be all the excuse I need to appropriate whatever I want.

But as an absolutist I don't actually think it is wrong, in fact I think cultural appropriation is required, maybe even hardwired.

616px-Frances_Densmore_recording_Mountain_Chief2.jpg
Is this Appropriation?

Life has been appropriating culture since life first appeared on the scene! The mitochondria in each one of our cells is a living history to how important appropriation has been for our species, and every other multi-cellular organism on the planet.

The important concept is to appropriate the best stuff, only the stuff that will help survive better in this strange world. We humans have a lot more KPIs nowadays than just survival, such as efficiency, enjoyment and productivity, so be sure that you are appropriating habits and traditions that improve whichever Key Performance Indicators are important to you!

images.jpeg
You can Change!

We change our culture all the time, for all sorts of reasons. Those that have recently adopted the 'stop cultural appropriation' meme just changed their culture to one that doesn't want any more change. But the no change party has never maintained victory for very long, and for good reason.

Change is our Super Power as Humans!

Love and Light to All!

Sort:  

You gave me a lot to think about here. HHMM!!!

brilliant article! I loved some of your examples where claiming cultural appropriation seems ridiculous.

the places I have seen the term "cultural appropriation" used (correctly) are a bit more narrow, and I think that distinction is worth making.

when people adopt something from a culture they otherwise show lack of respect for or knowledge about, for the sole means of making a profit, that is cultural appropriation.

for example, native american traditional crafts sold by a rich white artist with no ties to any tribe/custom. or dressing up in blackface at a mixed race party without understanding the historical significance of what this means to african americans.

to me adopting the mindset or adapting to a culture you are trying to live among is showing your willingness to learn and is a complement to the culture. holding oneself aloof and expecting that culture to adapt to you is a bit assinine. yet we all suffer from it.

I remember eating out in Greece and getting very upset with the waiters who would take ages to bring food (like 30 minutes). I saw this as lax service and rudeness, because in American culture it is, where in their culture, they are giving the diners a chance to converse and enjoy wine.

Understanding differences like that are crucial. But I agree, most of culture is appropriated, down to the very words we write.

Origin of culture
1400–50; late Middle English: tilling, place tilled (< Anglo-French) < Latin cultūra. See cult, -ure

What an excellent and thorough response. I find it simplest to differentiate between appreciation and appropriation.

indeed. and this is why she's my fave :)

As a child in Germany I liked to play cowboys and Indians (meaning Red Indians) with my friends and during carnival we also dressed up in costumes as such. We had no idea about the American genocide, we were just acting out what we had seen on TV. Nowadays some fools might call this cultural appropriation, but I think that´s just some authoritarians (leftish ones I guess) who just want to tell other people how to behave, trying to be important and occupy the moral highground. Unfortunately their probably well-meant intentions go against the highest good we have, individual freedom. So I say, if somebody, even an adult, wants to dress up as a Red Indian nobody has the right to forbid that.

likedeeler I did the same, at a time there was no taboo around it. In sixth grade we were still dealing with history books calling Indians "savages", so I had ten years of cultural baggage to dump.

to me it's about the respect you show to the culture, and thats difficult to ascertain in a social setting with people who dont understand your beliefs and values. words and concepts are stuck in our language and psyche at a young age, and trying to change life long habits of those who become attached to them is painful...

I was raised with the words "picnic" and "indian-giver", at a time before cultural awareness was a thing. It wasn't until i was corrected on it years later that I began to think about the history and meaning of each word. so we find that cultural bias also worms its way into what we have appropriated without our even knowing it.

another difficult thing about cultural appropriation is not knowing to the degree its ingrained into our religion and nationalism. The reality that second generation americans are told to "go back home" by fifth generation americans makes me want to pound my head on a rock, as does anyone who tries to convince me that Easter and Christmas are purely Christian holidays with no basis in pagan religion.

awareness of our own cultural bias is no easy task to master.

No one is trying to forbid it. Just saying its a dick move. And considering the shit they're being put through in the US, no wonder they're pissed.

I.... LOVE... THIS....
And you. 😍

I'm glad others feel the same way I do. Because of such a LOUD group of folks yelling about 'cultural appropriation' (which I've always viewed in the same way as you), I was terrified.... and to be fair, still am.

I don't wanna become a race (HUMAN RACE) of people wearing all grey and cutting their hair the same and eating the same food because everyone's too afraid to SHARE and LOVE. I DO want to 'identify' as a HUMAN, the other boxes are important, but only for descriptive use, not based on 'worth'. Duh. Folks, duh. 🤦🏼

It's downright insane and not logical... yet, it's the mainstream.

(Side note: It's stressful finding the 'right' emoji to use... cause THAT is cultural appropriation too, if I use the wrong color.)

I remember a couple of years ago a couple of white gals (yes, those damned white devils with their white skin tone) in Washington State got in some shit for 'appropriating' Mexicans because they had spent a large chunk of time in Mexico, learning the culture, came back to the states and open a food truck... with gasp Mexican food. It was a hot mess. And the political climate has only gotten worse.

Same problem with the Native American tradition... YEARS ago, I found them and was welcomed. Now? I'm too damned white and shouldn't even be allowed to pray and pass along the traditions.

Again... weird, illogical and downright ignorant.

But thank YOU for speaking on this. I'm getting braver every day.

Do Indian casino's count as cultural appropriation?
😂

....using another culture to profit from, would surely be in this category.
I'm fairly sure there wasn't a roulette wheel in North America pre European

.....or anyone except white people driving cars for that matter....mmmm

pesky logic....the left hate it.
They don't know how to use it.
😂

YOU make me proud every day. This is a very well thought out line of reasoning and I happen to agree with you.

I love you and can not wait to see you BOTH.

This is the type of thing I wake up thinking about ;p

I should have that guide up by thursday. Ledis has already begun theoretically packing in her mind, so we must be close <3

I am in such deep agreement with you on this topic!!

Great post! I love the picture of the machete and the flip flops! Very unique culture.

hehehehe... flipflops. WE call em THONGS here in oz ;)

Go here https://steemit.com/@a-a-a to get your post resteemed to over 72,000 followers.

I find it interesting that seeing culture as fluid is a perspective that is often shared by those who have experienced cultural transitions. My theory is that when a worldview is formed from within a single cultural context it can feel like a very solid and permanent structure, because from within it we can’t feel the subtle changes. But when a person steps outside of their cultural context and into another they become aware of the movement. When we move we must adapt. This is how cultures survive. They are living changing things because they are made up of living changing people. I think it is good to challenge popular movements and ask people to think more deeply about issues specifically so that positive change can be affected and not just a couple of buzz words tossed into the void for argument.

Your post had been curated by the @buildawhale team and mentioned here:

https://steemit.com/curation/@buildawhale/buildawhale-curation-digest-06-18-18

Keep up the good work and original content, everyone appreciates it!

Thank you, it is an honor!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.33
TRX 0.11
JST 0.034
BTC 66579.21
ETH 3282.19
USDT 1.00
SBD 4.30