You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: China Is Freer Than You Think
Did you know, China has some of the most restrictive censorship on what kind of movies can be allowed to play in their theaters? Most Hollywood movies would not make it to China's theaters without satisfying requirements and self imposed soft censorship.
In case you didn't notice, I did wrote "China certainly has many problems..."
Yes, we all know that televisions, movies, and the internet are all censored in China. But China also doesn't have a lot of the serious issues in the U.S., you'll know what I mean if you live there, or ask Winston why he would choose to live in China for so long...
I live in both places. Though I admit last time I was in China (mainland) was 2006 and never bothered going back.
In my opinion, China doesn't have serious issues because talking about serious issues are either not allowed, or their dissenting voices are silenced. Outside of these restricted issues, then sure you are fairly free to do or say whatever without breaking any laws. But that isn't real freedom, it's just an appearance of freedom.
But I will give credit that China has made tremendous economic progress. As long people are prosperous, I believe the issues can remain suppressed. China's true challenge will come when it faces the next economic slowdown as many of the serious issue may surface. I for one am still waiting to see China make progress in it's political system on the scale as its economic system. That will truly be a great day for the Chinese people.
What is the most serious problem in China, in your opinion? Specifically in relation with the "serious issues in the U.S." you mention...
Man, this can take a very long time, but let me just bring up some main problems in China (I don't have time right now to get into the U.S. issues). 1) Air, water, and soil pollution. With most of the world's factories located in China, it's extremely difficult to clean up the main cities. Even if the factories all run on green energy (which the Chinese government is trying to do), they would still produce lots of toxic waste. The consumers of this planet all have responsibilities on this issue. 2) The lack of traffic enforcement. I know it's not easy to properly divert that insane number of cars, but the Chinese government could certainly do a lot more enforcement than they are right now. Driving or crossing the street on foot in China is way too stressful. 3) The refusal to crack down on scams and copyright infringements. While violent crimes are relatively low in China, non-violent ones are high. 4) Excessive censorship can hinder China's intellectual development. China is not only huge geographically, it has tons of very different cultures, resulting in lots of civil wars for centuries. Also, China was invaded by at least 9 countries previously, during the time when China lacked unity and was vulnerable. These are the main reasons why the Chinese government has been censoring the media so heavily, they are afraid that without strict control and order, the country would fall apart and become the victim of foreign invasion again. While they are gradually reducing the censorship, it's still not fast enough to induce a reasonable intellectual growth in China.
Very interesting.
What is the primary reason you think the Chinese Govt censors things?
To blakemiles84: I don't know why there's no reply button on your 2nd question. The primary reasons for the censorship were in the 4th problem I wrote; which are to prevent division & civil wars within the country, and to minimize foreign attacks & propaganda. To a lesser degree, another reason would be that the the ruling Chinese families are afraid of losing power/money.