A future of distribution bots
The longer that @ocdb has been running the more I'm thinking about the impact it could have on Steem in the long run.
As we know, at current voting algorithm the incentive to curate compared to the returns you can do with other bid bots simply isn't there.
Let's think about what a bid bot does. In simple terms, it let's a buyer buy a vote to get onto trending, the more bots there are the more votes that buyer can stack on top to guarantee the trending spot. I haven't looked but unfortunately at times like these when there isn't as much demand, a lot of bid bots will sit idle without bids for some time every 24 hours. Not only that but people use them for profit because of the lack of competition, meaning they may just use them for that without trying to get onto trending - which kind of defeats the purpose of "promotion bot".
If bid bots cost each time you want to use them for promotion, the buyers would lose out on rewards which would go to the bot owners and delegators but at the same time it would benefit all stakeholders as they had to use more Steem than they got back.
After having experimented with @ocdbfund for a while, I got to thinking. Since I've been using that account to grow a fund for a while, what about bid bot owners that would buy votes with alt accounts just to never let the bot go idle. After all they have an incentive to keep their delegators happy with max ROI and it directly also effects their own profit, since they take a cut from each buy + curation rewards in some cases. I am not accusing any current bid bot owners to be doing this, I'm just saying there is a possibility.
Although I do believe that there will always be bid bots that are profitable and there will be some demand, I think that at times like these where activity has dropped with price and demand for them, maybe we should start focusing on distribution more.
Imagine a distribution bot that would constantly grow its whitelist and have more and more unique daily users using it. Everyone with low stake would be growing at a steady pace, balancing distribution over time. Bids can be lower depending on the demand, and grow depending on the increase in delegation. Imagine what that would do for distribution and a more balanced, curated and healthy place this would be with a much higher "middle-class". The best part about it would be that the whole system keeping this distribution together has already been built and isn't requiring delegators to constantly pay them a cut for a job done over a year ago.
I'm happy for my community that @ocdb has been welcomed and a lot of interest has come together around it and it has grown fast and I think more and more people will realize that instead of trying to fight the bad actors/spammers/scammers with blacklists and flags, let's instead just reward the decent members of the community more so they can help keep this place clean and something everyone wants to use.
I've thought a lot about it, and I really can't think of many cons towards this distribution bot if it would grow heavily in the future. Can you think of any? Like, I'm asking cause if there is something that could help it improve in time I would happily rethink the whole model.
The people who've put the bot and the list together, which I want to thank, @jga, @theuxyeti, @pharesim and every single @ocd curator which would make this list way too long. They've been helping a long because they do a lot for the Steem blockchain and community and want to see this place grow into something amazing like many others.
I just wanted to think about these things and how they could improve the future, that's why I wanted to write some words down and ask the community about their thoughts and any possible improvements they could think of that would help all of us, please feel free to share so in the comments, thanks!
The Bidbots I have used lately haven't shown any profit at all. In fact I lost 16 Steem on the last post that I tried to promote, preventing me from considering using bots in the future.
I never actually intended to use them in the first place, but when you spend 2 hours on a post it's sometimes a good idea to try to get some exposure these days, fwiw.
That's great. In a time of people blaming steemit for not being rewarding and at the same time promoting sites like scorum, people like you who still think about steem are really encouraging us investors to invest more over here. Your optimistic approach says that all. I believe that We do really have a great future!
I don’t really understand. Would the distribution bot just upvote whitelisted users without them paying anything? So it just acts as a curation fund?
Posted using Partiko iOS
They'd still send it bids but it returns a guaranteed profit of 10%. The profits that would usually go to the owners of the bot go instead to the authors.
The author that sent the bid, or a group of whitelisted authors? Or would it be like ocdb where only whitelisted authors can send bids? That sounds pretty cool 😊🤔
This is absolutely the way to clean up those trending and hot tabs!!!
How can someone be part of this initiative? I'm not a ocdb member ( I would like to be) but I still like the idea. What are the requirements for a investor/supporter of the project? How can it be used and help the smaller minnows? Is there a joint effort within projects and communities to have something like that?
Posted using Partiko Android
Great progress so far. Delegated 50% of my small stake.
Such bots are the right way, but they don't help so much the distribution, because the most profit is still made by the delegators what means that those that have the most will still make the most.
Posted using Partiko Android
@Acidyo, a couple of months ago I used to use bid bots and you could take advantage of low bids to profit from the bidding cycle. About four or five months ago that changed as it seemed that the bot code was tweaked all around that ensured you could no longer really profit from a bid even if yours is the only bid.
That basically put me off completely from using the bid bots because that is practically greed on the bot owners part because the value of your bid was always fixed regardless.
That is why when I came across OCD I was actually relieved that there was a project out there that would allow me to grow my Steem Power confidently each day. My vote is basically worthless at the moment even though I have some people on autovote. I would love to see that change with the help of OCD over the next year if I find myself in the whitelist.
Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your UA account score is currently 7.954 which ranks you at #33 across all Steem accounts.
Your rank has not changed in the last three days.
In our last Algorithmic Curation Round, consisting of 368 contributions, your post is ranked at #11.
Evaluation of your UA score:
Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server