Art and Creativity: We LOVE What You Do! (But we just don't want to PAY for it...)

in #art7 years ago

Most forms of creativity-- be it art, music, writing or some other field-- tends to involve "sales" at some point in the process.

After all-- unless we're pure hobbyists-- we have to get our art in front of people; we have to find venues for our music; we have to find publishers for our manuscripts... and then we have to persuade someone that we should be fairly compensated for our efforts.

The Nature of the "Starving Artist"

KrampusKitten
"Krampus Kitten" print from original watercolour by Braden Duncan

Few of us have gone through life without running into the term "Starving Artist." Or musician. Or actor. Or writer.

But is that a myth or a real thing? And how did it come about?

Sadly, I know very few artists and creatives who are making anything that resembles a "comfortable living" from their creativity. Many are "just scraping by" and even more hold jobs doing something else, purely to pay the bills and cost of staying alive.

One of the things I share in common with most of my fellow creatives is that I just really don't like sales. And I especially don't like selling myself

One of the reasons we decided to create the Red Dragonfly as a straight "commission gallery" is that we strongly felt that the artists we promote should have to "do retail." And-- when we took over the gallery in 2016-- it was fairly clear that part of the reason for its prior decline towards demise was precisely that it had tried to exist as a cooperative.

Something For Nothing

Having spent many years as a struggling writer, I discovered early on that writing tends to be a fairly exploitative field. 

BagdadTheatre
"Bagdad Theatre, Portland" original pen and pencil drawing by Kira Mardikes

Many a time did I come across an editor who would assure me that my article (or other contribution) was "excellent," but that would be followed up with the inevitable phrase "Unfortunately, we can't actually PAY contributors at the moment, but this will look great on your resume!

Of course, we all know that you can't actually pay for groceries or electricity with that, but many neophyte creatives find themselves in such situations. In the case of musicians, gigs are offered "for the exposure.

In the case of artists, the "something for nothing" trap often comes in the form of cooperative galleries that are quick to charge a monthly participation fee, but does very little for the artist in return... the only thing that really matters is that the artist pays the monthly "rent" and works at the gallery one or more times a week. And when the artist balks, the response is usually "Yeah, but your work is in a gallery!"

It becomes problematic because just like everyone else, artists to have to eat.

How To Deal With This Issue

Part of the reason artists and creatives often get trapped in these patterns is because we haven't taken adequate time to put a value on what we do. Seasoned artists have less of an issue with giving themselves away for free than newcomers who tend to be eager to get their work seen.

The main piece of advice we give to artists at the gallery is "Your work has value.

Maybe that sounds obvious, but surprisingly many young hopefuls have done very little to assess what "fair value" is for their work. Some err on the high side, but many err on the side of practically giving things away. The thing to keep in mind here is that you're trying to build a reputation and following... and that you will not "represent" well if you're too generous.

Some artists tell us that they are really "not in it for the money" and that can be fair enough. However, you should be able to at least cover the replacement cost of art supplies, as well as earn a contribution towards your basic living, even if your art cannot wholly support itself.

Thank you for reading! Red Dragonfly is a proud member of the @sndbox creative initiative.

The Red Dragonfly is an independent alternative art gallery located in Port Townsend, WA; showcasing edgy and unique contemporary art & handmade crafts by local and worldwide artists. All images are our own, unless otherwise credited. Where applicable, artist images used with permission.  

Sort:  

I"m always confused when I hear artists say they're "not in it for the money" .
Who is?? No one chooses the art field thinking "cool, this is where the money is" LOL!! The point is that all of us - whether art is our main livelihood or not need to be supported enough to continue making the work. As we've both acknowledged in previous posts and conversations, being compensated not only feels great but helps validate and grow the value of our work.

I've come to believe that when we sell our work at too low a price we do a disservice to all other artists and makers of all genres because we perpetuate the idea that this is worth very little money and maybe even of very little value.

Thanks for the great post as always @reddragonfly!
PS. 2 questions - are you going to steemfest? and would you be interested in a NW steemit meet-up in Seattle? I've wanted to put one together for a long time but didn't have the bandwidth but I'm ready. If so, I'll put out a post and with your help we can get the word out. I'm on steemitchat as Ruth Greenberg if you want to dm about this.

I know we are pretty aligned on this-- I'm trying to lay some groundwork with these articles, ahead of getting to the question of how to arrive at "fair value" and also how we need to look at our individual "artistic self-esteem" as part of how we value our work... going slowly with it as I hope this blog will gain some traction, both with established and new artists... simply because we need to HAVE these conversations.

I also agree that people do a disservice by undervaluing their work. My (early) background is actually in finance and economics, along with marketing... and "price" is one of the least sticky competitive tools. If I offer mine for $10, there will always be someone willing to sell for $9.50 and so on... and all we really succeed in doing to starve each other to death. Meanwhile, we devalue whatever it is we're creating.

Not going to Steemfest this time-- just don't have the means or the time to leave what I am doing right now. Wish I could...

A NW Steemit meetup in Seattle would be cool, though... although I'd probably not be of much use until winter/early spring. In my mind, I've been quietly noodling the idea of some kind of "SteemArt Northwest" guild around... possibly as an extension of (cooperation with?) Sndbox. Very early stages on that, however.

We are definitely aligned in this and I love commenting on your posts because you always raise issues I'm passionate about. Smart strategy to lay the ground work as you are and what great subjects - fair value and artistic self-esteem - brilliant!!

I'm not going to steemfest either for exactly the same reasons and am kind of heartbroken about it. Last year I was sure I would be able to go this year but life hasn't been so predictable. In any case, if I organized a meet up for Mid November, would you be able to come? I'm going to try to message you in steemit chat about this now but if you dont find my message, my email is [email protected].

oh yes and a NW Guild is a fantastic idea, count me in...we can discuss but I love the idea

And if all that came from the fact that we are in a society that value the work only and above all , "the work" in the sense you have to make something unpleasant in which you put a lot of effort to appear as a brave and courageous person that do something of her life, that brings money to buy bills and eventually some leisures..?

Why when you have people like artistes/ creators that dare to come with a product they had pleasure to do, they even had fun and probably much enjoyment

(because nobody choose to be an artist to earn money, being an artist is chosen as a necessity by the soul for its own fulfillment, which is a totally different approach...),

so when an artist comes with his product, people around are not very willing to give it the value of "the work" as it is painfully known...just because we enjoyed ourself in the process makes us (and everybody) think it is not work, therefore it has no value...here are the false premises... ^_^
takeiteasy.png

From my experience, there are two opposite directions going there.

As an artist, I am NOT "in it for the money," but I am grateful to be paid for what I do, so I can purchase art supplies and dinner and electricity and things.

People who SEE artists say "you should not be in it for the money," but attached to that is an unspoken expectation "therefore you should be quite happy to simply give away your work..." As you said, a false premise... we don't say to the doctor "because you ENJOY healing people, your work should be free..."

The "something for nothing" seems to be a bad approach in many fields of activities. When I was a project planner and fund raiser some organisations asked me if I could do it for them just for "glory", but I can eat the "glory" so I've always said "no, thanks". In the art field (as in all creative fields) it's worse! There are many people that take advantage of ingenuity of young artists (not "young" in age, but in the world of art) in very bad way. Someone ask artworks for free (for "glory") others ask more money just to expose artwork in a totally new shop. Here in Italy we have many "place" (I really can't call them "gallery"), also here in form of cooperative, that ask hight partecipation fee just to expose the artwork in a room that nobody knows. I always say that it's always better to pay an high commission for sale in a "real" gallery than to pay for a simple space on the wall that nobody can see ^_^

Used to see it in the marketing business, too. As part of an independent marketing specialist being considered for a project, one of the "requirements" would go something like "Well, as part of the consideration, why don't you make a proposal on how you would approach this project." Then they submit the proposal with the application, they DON'T hire you, but they use your plan which they basically got for free.

Similar things happen for commercial graphic artists working in advertising. "Send us some examples of your work," which then become free art.

I totally agree with you. Artists have to eat, too!
When I told my mom I wanted to be a writer when I was a teenager, the first thing she told me was "But writers are poor!" I want to prove her wrong.

Funny... that's precisely what my mother told me, as well. Then she said I should just write as a "hobby" and get a real job instead.

From my experience and point of view, when art is created for commercial purpose it looses it's artistic properties. So an artist should create art for the sake of it and money would naturally come to him, as long as he puts a reasonable price to it, which does not undervalue his work. At least that is what I like to believe.
Best option is to pretend he is dead, so his art can be appreciated more :D this was kind of a joke ;)

Joke or not, it's a shame so many artists' work do not get much value until the artist is dead.

As I see it, I create "for creating's sake." Getting paid for what I create, allows me to take more time to create. If I do NOT get paid, then I have to spend my creative time working at the supermarket, or as a bartender, or whatever... and during those hours NO ART is created.

It is a true struggle when a inspiration wants to manifest itself and you have to work a dead-end job. Been in this situation and right now I am trying to make a change in my life to make a living through art.

I hope it happens for you soon @gabchik, who knows maybe steemit can help

Thank you so much for the kind words. I am sure that steemit will help one way or another. Even though my trip posts earn much more than my art ones.

I believe it's important to post about what you care about regardless of rewards and if the art matters to you, then do it for yourself and do the travel for others ;-). I post about subjects that I'm pretty sure people don't really read but I need to express and practice developing my ideas and voice so I do it for me regardless. Keeping it meaningful for me is the only way I can keep committed here and of course the good friends help immeasurably too !

art creation is a treasure for every artist even if it's no value to others... the great feeling when you finish your master piece!

Agreed, it is great to work simply doing "art, for art's sake."

I general, I have to go to work to make a living... so I have less time for art than I would like to. But such is life.

Excellent article. I am doing my first book signing tomorrow and selling my books for a hefty $10. This reinforces the type of thinking that is needed to put your price on the high side--"your work has value".

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.15
JST 0.029
BTC 63294.77
ETH 2638.69
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.70