HELP ME CHOOSE!
I have a decision to make, and I’m going to do something that’s a little funky. I’m going to ask for your help and input.
I’m a writer and comic creator, but I can’t draw worth a damn. That means I have to hire artists to adapt my words into visual awesomeness. I am just beginning my journey on the way to publishing a (semi) historical graphic novel about the trial and execution of Socrates in ancient Athens. I’ve recently had a bunch of artists submit their work to join my team, and I’ve narrowed the candidates to a Final Four.
I don’t know about you, but sometimes decisions can be excruciating. Especially when you have to decide between some clearly talented individuals. So I’m asking the Steemit community to weigh in: who would be your top pick out of the art samples below?
A few things to keep in mind: these samples are black and white inked pages, rather than final colored and lettered pages; apart from talent, I also have to weigh details like price and language barrier (some candidates are from another country); but based solely on the artist’s craft and style, who’s your top pick?
#1.
![SamirSample.jpg](https://steemitimages.com/DQmaKG3d9VU6jctKjL7LxPjGbHuQaaJ3isvVvTDLiJANdHr/SamirSample.jpg)
Source
#2.
![GianSample.jpg](https://steemitimages.com/640x0/https://steemitimages.com/DQmWAkgTNaZheuoo6ox9RGYqoZRDfvPSJ7njRJP75FK5LuZ/GianSample.jpg)
Source
#3.
![GeneSample.jpg](https://steemitimages.com/DQmfJP6B7kKHhtTEVrQydmhHHn4NXWr7WPcvk4SuEGffdAw/GeneSample.jpg)
Source
#4. (this last one the artist sent me finished pages - so try not to let that weigh your vote!)
![DanielSample.jpg](https://steemitimages.com/640x0/https://steemitimages.com/DQmTB8pNbfiVmGFSDPXeBkXRCiYnaNaK5FVaX9yoMwNtEJs/DanielSample.jpg)
Source
Thanks for all your comments and feedback! I’m brand spanking new to Steemit, and I plan to share my progress as I move forward with this graphic novel - so if that sounds like it could interest you, give me a follow!
Your art is really really nice, i hope to get to that level of inking someday ^^
Hi imaginalex - I just want to clarify - these are samples of separate artists - not me. :) But I agree, they are all pretty awesome.
I agree #2 hands down. Great composition & draftsmanship and the style just screams that it’s the best fit for the planned story. I’ll have to take a few minutes and peruse more of their websites... I’ll remark again if someone changes my mind!
Great to have you here and showing this process. I love seeing projects develop!
Thanks - that's awesome to take a look at their pages. I tried to select what I thought was the artist's best sample - but that too is subjective. :)
I like #2 best.
Thanks!
Definitley #2, though they are all very talented.
I agree with everyone's reply (so far) #2 is my pick for the artistry alone. The style seems like it would best fit your subject matter as well.
I choose #2 sir..
Number 2 I draw the most emotion from but I really enjoy the colour in the last one.
Okay - wow! Looks like it's unanimous. I must say, I'm a little surprised everyone is in absolute agreement. I was definitely leaning toward #2 - especially considering, as many of you mentioned, the style probably will work best for the historical realism of the story.
At the same time, as I was uploading the art to this blog post, I was like, oh, wow, that's really pretty good. Wait, this one is good too! Heh.
Thanks for your help!
They're all good but I like #3 the most.