Monet and Manet? Is the Difference More than Just O and A?
It is very easy to confuse two different artists from the same city with almost the same family names who lived at the same time.
Argenteuil. Monet
Bank of the Siene at Argenteuil. Manet
Their acquaintance started with a big conflict but later they became big friends.
Claude Monet. Self- portrait with a beret
Edouard Manet. Self - portrait with a palette
The reason of the fight was Edouard's Manet's expectations from the salon in 1865. He exhibited his new painting "Olympia".
At the salon he heard appraisal exclamations to the family name that sounded like his but they were about landscapes and not about his "Olympia". He even thought that somebody used his name to get his fame. But it were landscapes by the unknown Claude Monet who made his debut.
Monet and Manet had much in common. They both created in impressionism style although Manet was closer to realism. Edouard Manet didn't consider himself an impressionist but newspaper critics called him a "king of impressionists" and young artists, future impressionists as "Manet's team".
They were both French and lived at the end of the 19th century.
On the internet you can find the easiest way to differ the paintings of these two artists. Monet is spots, Manet is people.
But if it was that easy. Even people who are not that bad in art will have a problem to identify where is "the Grand Channel in Venice" by Monet and where "The Grand Channel in Venice" by Manet.
The Grand Channel in Venice. Claude Monet
The Grand Channel in Venice. Edouard Manet
Edouard Manet was always close to realism. Some art experts even considered him as not an impressionist but first modernist. So, the more real the painting looks the bigger chance the artist was Manet. Monet although had some realistic works in the beginning too.
Monet was mostly interested in colour and its influence on the emotions of the spectator. So, if there are colours, light and their collaboration it is Monet.
For Manet volume was important. For example "A Bar at the Folies-Bergère" has a very complicated composition and volume.
Edouard Manet. A Bar at the Folies Bergere
The Grand Channel is not the only plot which would make you think who is who. Once both artists looked out their windows. Monet was impressed with the colours and he painted a red - white - blue holiday. Manet got used to notice people on streets and he saw a bit different picture, a one - legged soldier who didn't let France forget about their shame war 7 years ago.
The Rue Mosnier with Flags. Edouard Manet
The Rue Montgueil in Paris. Claude Monet
Edouard and Claude were big friends untill Manet's death. The spectators at the salon didn't value his painting "Luncheon on the grass" and for Monet it was like a revolution, a breath of fresh air, life itself.
And in 2 years he painted his "Luncheon on the grass" as a sign of respect.
And "Luncheon on the grass" by Picasso. Just for fun.)))
Monet-Manet is a story of long friendship which was based on big respect and money. When Monet had tough times he wrote Manet letters that the money borrowed from Manet ran out and he wanted to borrow some more. Manet never refused and after he learnt about the illness of Camilla, Monet's first wife, he just wrote off all Claude's debts.
In 6 years after the death of Edouard Manet one American collector would like to buy "Olympia" for 20 000 francs. Monet gave up painting for a half year and became a bookkeeper and PR - specialist to organize a money collection to buy the painting and give it to France.
The more I read about artists the more I am impressed with their characters. They were not just big talents but also real people with big hearts. And, of course, I have loved Claude Monet for many - many years already.
Sources:
http://lesiksarthistory.blogspot.ru/2012/04/rue-montorgueil-vs-rue-mosnier-with.html
http://mentalfloss.com/article/72782/15-things-you-might-not-know-about-manets-luncheon-grass
http://www.theartstory.org/artist-monet-claude.htm
http://www.manet.org/
This post has been ranked within the top 80 most undervalued posts in the second half of Nov 29. We estimate that this post is undervalued by $4.78 as compared to a scenario in which every voter had an equal say.
See the full rankings and details in The Daily Tribune: Nov 29 - Part II. You can also read about some of our methodology, data analysis and technical details in our initial post.
If you are the author and would prefer not to receive these comments, simply reply "Stop" to this comment.
There are some similarities in their styles I think but I think it is the names that cause the confusion. Both were fantastic artists and I love the story of friendship between them.
You are right. There are similarities. I would definitely think the second Grand Channel is also by Monet. And the bank of the Siene.
It's always good to learn about the master's. Thank you.
Thank you!
Hello @aksinya that you for this. I love reading this sort of insight into artists and their work.
I loved the TV series by Sister Wendy - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendy_Beckett
It was hugely popular. So the more of this sort of post the better for Steemit I think.
I have followed you, upvoted and resteemed. ;-)
Thank you very much! And I will check it!
I found this very helpful. Thank you! I've always felt a bit embarrassed by not knowing the difference between these two painters.