Disobedience is a Virtue

in anarchy •  2 years ago 

In a couple videos recently I’ve worn my new shirt, from “Principled Propaganda” (http://www.principledpropaganda.com), which says, “disobedience is the true foundation of liberty.” It makes for a catchy slogan, but it also happens to be a profound truth.

Consider the situation from the viewpoint of a tyrant. If his subjects are constantly bitching and moaning, saying nasty things about him, saying how they want someone else in charge, etc., while they all continue to obey his commands—complying with his “laws” and paying his “taxes”—and even condemning any who don’t obey his commands as nasty “criminals”—then the tyrant knows his power is secure, and he has nothing to fear.

There is a world of difference between, on the one hand, someone who complains about what the rulers are doing today, while continuing to believe that there need to be rulers, over him and over everyone else, and, on the other hand, someone who knows that there is no such thing, and can be no such thing, as a legitimate ruler. Only the latter poses any real threat to those in power.

Even some anarchists and voluntaryists don’t quite seem to grasp the difference, especially those who are still trying to use the political process to achieve freedom. What all such action implies, even if this is accidental, is that we mere peasants cannot be free, and should not be free, unless and until we can get some “elected officials” on the throne who will give us their legislative permission to be free. Voting and petitioning merely reinforces the idea that it is up to the ruling class whether we are allowed to be free or not. The two giant problems with this are: 1) those who seek positions of “authority” have never, and will never, give permission to the peasants to not be ruled, and; 2) If you think you need someone else’s permission to be free, you are already a slave inside your own head.

Even among some who intellectually and philosophically understand the concepts of self-ownership, non-aggression and voluntaryism, there can still be a strong residual psychological instinct to obey perceived “authorities.” I admit to feeling that for a long time myself, years after becoming an anarchist, even when I already knew how insane and destructive that impulse is. Most of us, by way of the same general structure used in the Prussian “education” system, have undergone prolonged and intensive psychological indoctrination which was specifically designed to train us to bow to and obey supposed “authorities.” If you want an eye-opening, stomach-churning example of just how well such indoctrination works, read “Obedience to Authority” by Dr. Stanley Milgram.

And even when our rational mind knows something to be true, our habits, instincts, fears, familiar patterns of thought, and trained-in Pavlovian responses can take a long time to outgrow. When we spent most of our formative years being bombarded with the message—from parents, teachers, the media, agents of the state, etc.—that obedience is a virtue and disobedience is a sin, we “learn” that lie at a very deep psychological level, way beyond merely an intellectual understanding. As a result, it can take a long time for such a lie to be thoroughly rooted out.

I will leave you with an important yet depressing example. Look how many proud Americans, while rejoicing in their supposed “freedom,” continue to clamor and beg the political elite to grant their holy permission for the slave class to please be robbed a little less, by begging for “tax cuts.” What a pathetic spectacle it is to watch tens of millions of armed human beings begging a handful of crooks in Washington to please let the rest of us keep more of what we produce. Meanwhile, if a tenth of those people had the mental and psychological fortitude to simply disobey, the IRS would very quickly be history.

And yet, of all those proud Muricans who rant and rave, “demanding” that Congress do this or that (using “demands” which are backed by nothing, and so are not demands at all), the vast majority continue to firmly believe that they have a moral obligation to pay tribute to the ruling class via “taxes,” and to obey their every ridiculous legislative decree. They are nothing more than slaves begging their masters for mercy, while continuing to serve him whether he shows mercy or not. Some of the terminology may have changed, but the mind control and indoctrination is the same as it ever was.

To make a contented slave, you must make a thoughtless one. It is necessary to darken his moral and mental vision, and, as far as possible, to annihilate his power of reason. He must be able to detect no inconsistencies in slavery. The man that takes his earnings, must be able to convince him that he has a perfect right to do so. It must not depend upon mere force; the slave must know no Higher Law than his master's will. The whole relationship must not only demonstrate, to his mind, its necessity, but its absolute rightfulness.” - Frederick Douglass (former slave)

# - # - # - # - # - # - # - # - # - # - # - # - # - #

(P.S. If you find value in the writings, videos, or other works of Larken Rose, or want to support the making of “The Mirror,” feel free to support his efforts by PayPal (to “[email protected]”) or Bitcoin (1MXWFg6KyDBVqNSXHBXHCpXc16DDy7QQVm), or through Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/user?u=347021).)

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Very good @larkenrose ...I'll make a video with this as the text so we can get the message out to an even broader audience. I'll add your links to the video and, hopefully, bring you some traffic via my YouTube channel. Peace my friend!

Also... @dollarvigilante if you see this, let's hook up...I wanna introduce my YT audience to you as well - contact me.


Hey man, we've been in contact via email, no? Email is best to contact me.


@dollarvigilante -- [email protected] hit me up. Sorry if I've dropped the ball. As I'm sure happens to you, my emails get covered up very quickly.

The hard part for me is whether or not I am already following some other unconscious tyrant in my mind when I am disobeying, whether my dissidence is already unconsciously a operation of the state in some indirect form.

excellent post @larkenrose
i cannot agree more...disobedience is truly a virtue as when its done well can get positive results an kickstart a revolutionary trend which can help change societies for the better...if the Zimbabwean army did not disobey that tyrant of a president in the person of Mugabe and ensure his party kickstarts the process of his removal...the country will fall deeper into trouble waters with the plans to install his wife as successor...thanks for sharing

Upvoted, re$teemed & following!

Obedience isn't a virtue, but that doesn't mean disobedience IS a virtue.

Obedience isn't a moral issue.

To obey someone is simply to submit to their authority - to do as they command. I regularly submit to the authority of my doctor, my wife and even my children. When I believe their authority in an area of knowledge or skill is greater than my own, I happily submit to them because they've earned my trust.

Obedience isn't a moral issue and thus disobedience is NOT a virtue.


Yes, I think you are right. But I think Larken Rose meant disobeying the government is a virtue.


It seems you confuse 'obedience' with accepting advice, or even acceding to demands. Your doctor better not be issuing you commands, while your familial relationships are none of my bidness.

Taking advice, or appeasing your kids, is NOT obedience.


No I'm not confusing following advice with obedience.

For example, if my wife suggests I wear different clothes to an event, I might disagree, but her previously earned authority in the area of clothes selection makes me put my objections to the side and obey her orders.

And if my child tells me to do X in a game when I really want to do Y - again, I will follow their advice despite my objections because of their earned authority in that area.

The claim that "disobedience is a virtue" only when applied to the government is also retarded. Disobedience would mean doing the opposite of what is demanded in all circumstances. How is that universalizable?

The whole premise of the article is flawed.


"...if my wife suggests...[I]obey her orders."

I submit you are conflating different things.

And, government always seems retarded, because it is always being abused for the benefit of the corrupt officials that worm their way into power.

While disobedience isn't something that should always be undertaken, at least not for children, who require loving guidance that includes commands, such as "Do not leap into that blazing fire!", it is always a virtue for free adults.

Don't tell me what to do.

Anyone that gives you orders reduces you to chattel. If you obey them, that is.


very Good post Millions vote post.. i like it

What a piece of utopia to aspire to, such a state where no man is another's ruler! Another's master!

Hey Larken! I still remember reading your material about the Income Tax. Good stuff!

Weren't you jailed for sharing this material?


As you point out, making demand isn't humbly begging, and can only be undertaken from a position of strength.

Fractured, divided, and conquered, we are hardly in position to make demands.

I learned this by being fractured, divided, and conquered, in my youth, making demands without strength, and know better than to invite such oppression again, absent damn good reason - and backup.

Thanks for again pointing out honest truths!