Resteem cliques, community discovery, Steem, and social platform mechanisms
Recently on Steem I was exploring the followers of an account I really like (it posts good content and I was hoping to find similar content among its followers/followings), when I kept running into accounts that resteemed the exact same set of posts, in the exact same order.
Being a social platform nerd for my day job, a couple possibilities jumped out:
- These accounts are a voting ring, boosting each other/or are sock puppets for single entity
- These accounts are not sock puppets, but in a "white hat" resteem ring (maybe via handing credentials over to well-intentioned app that is resteeming the same posts across all accounts in same order)
I then started to wonder how Steem uses community detection.
Does it follow other commercial platforms with similar "upvoting" mechanisms (which shall remain nameless :D)? These commercial sites shadow-ignore upvotes that come from voting rings (they allow the votes, and the total votes is reflected in the tally, but they don't contribute any weight to algorithm that ranks the story for things like "hot" or "trending" or "popular" or "front page").
(Side note: even the SEC uses community detection to help track down insider trading).
But community detection isn't only used to find fraud and bad actors. It can also be used for other stuff, like recommendation systems. Say... to suggest an account to follow or a piece of content you may want to check out.
Has anybody done Steem research with this? (Official or third party/independent stuff.)
Would love to check out any links you can recommend.
If you don't have any recommendations for me, but now are curious about the field, here's a video I like about topic-based community detection on Twitter.
PS- I probably didn't make it clear, but community detection has plenty of non-online-social network application, including important physical science stuff. I just didn't bring it up coz that's not my lane.
The last speculation I haver heard is that of the 105K accounts, less than half are active, about 3K are real people..the rest are bots.
Gaming the system in other words.
The 're-steem' feature looks more like a bug all the time.
Are there rewards for resteeming? I may have missed something when it was first added to Steemit. Other than providing more visibility for the shared author, does the account sharing benefit in some way? Thanks.
There are no first-order rewards for resteeming. But if you also upvoted the post (curated), you're boosting its ability to earn you second order rewards (curation rewards).
Thanks - Your explanation makes sense to me.
Where did you hear that? I'd be interested to read that info myself. Thanks
Network analysis is really interesting. I've seen it used to find out how science information gets passed around, to determine who are the influential people or organizations that can help get information out. And to find out what organizations are really on the outside, talking to themselves or just a small set of people. It can provide some interesting surprises. It would be cool to see that on Steemit -- and not just from posts, but related to comments and upvotes, too.
This post has been linked to from another place on Steem.
Learn more about and upvote to support linkback bot v0.5. Flag this comment if you don't want the bot to continue posting linkbacks for your posts.
Built by @ontofractal
Can you get ahold of me at [email protected] on google hangouts to discuss the tools that you'd need to do SNA on steemit? I've built some tools, and would love to hear about anything else that would make this analysis easier. Also happy to show you how to fire up a local steem daemon to be able to query the api directly if that's the kind of thing that tickles your fancy :).