Science and Photography Challenge: Light Reflection on a Curved Surface

in #science7 years ago (edited)

This contest is a science/photography contest and can be done in either a photography type method, or a science fair type method. This contest is being done in the name of science, but you do not need to be a scientist or perform any scientific experiments or data in order to participate. Anyone with a camera and a little creativity will be both contributing to the cause of science, and getting a chance to win.

What is the Contest About?

While everyone is familiar with crowdsourcing for money, the internet also allows us to crowdsource information. And we are crowdsourcing the testing of and attempt to falsify the hypothesis that light can only reflect in a straight line to the viewer on a flat surface.

Your mission, if you choose to accept it, is to photograph a light source shining across a curved (concave or convex) surface to emulate, as much as possible, the reflection of the sun setting on the ocean with a light source in the distance, and the reflection of the light source in as straight a line as possible directly towards the viewer, as seen in the image below.

()
Image Credit: Pixabay

I have an image below as an example. Some ideas to accomplish this are:

  1. A curved bridge at night with a light over it. A wet bridge is best
  2. A child's slide with someone holding a light source at the top. Either an old style metal slide or a wet slide would be best
  3. A curved shiny surfaced building or structure, such as the St. Louis Arch
  4. Build a curved model, cover it with tinfoil, place the light at the top of the curve, and shoot the image.
  5. Anything else your heart desires
  6. You could even find an image online that is an excellent example, so long as the image is in the public domain or you have permission or rights to use it. Just attribute the image appropriately.

light  curvature reflection bridge.jpg
Image credit: my own. Beautiful evening in Inverness, Scotland

The object you photograph can be in nature, like the sun shining on the St. Louis Arch, or it can be artificially prepared. It can be as small as a something you caught in a microscope, or as large as a mountainside.

The Prizes

At least 3 prizes will be awarded, chosen by me based on creativity, beauty, degree of curvature, the wow factor, and the close emulation of the image above of a sunset on water. I may add more prizes if the post reward is high. The rewards will be as follows and be awarded in SBD:

First place: 30 SBD
Second place: 15 SBD
Third place: 10 SBD

I will personally upvote each entry, so long as it meets the requirements, so everyone who qualifies and puts in a reasonable effort to emulate the image will win something.

The rules:

  1. Upvote this post
  2. Follow me
  3. Do your own post and put the link to the post in a reply to THIS post
  4. Include the phrase, "Light Reflection on Curved Surface" in the post title
  5. Two of your tags should be: flatearth and reflection-challenge
  6. You can do either a video or images, or both.
  7. In either case, please include in your post 2 still shots: one of the image, and one that includes clear proof of curvature (concave or convex) by methods to be determined best by you, but could include a side shot of the object, or an image of a level sitting on the object
  8. Attribute your images appropriately, even if they are yours
  9. One entry per person
  10. Entry will be accepted no later than October 10th at midnight EST
  11. Your entry will be permission for me to use your images in any subsequent compilation posts. Attribution will be made to your original post.
  12. Have fun and be creative

BONUS #1: If you do a science-type writeup explaining the science of light, and why light can reflect in a straight line off of a curved surface, I will also resteem your post.

Bonus #2: Earn a change to win 1 SBD by entering your photo into @Juliank 's Ongoing Photo Contest

I will attempt to announce the winners on or around October 15th, but will reserve the right to have a week's leeway if needed.

Good luck. I look forward to seeing your entries.

Sort:  

strawman argument again. you are not doing science, but biased research.

Falsifying a claim is how science is done. Your are making unsupported accusations. I've asked you to refrain from commenting here with unsupported accusations, unsupported claims, and dropping videos or memes.

the picture supports the argument.

you run from the truth.

It does not support the argument, it makes an UNSUPPORTED CLAIM that it cannot happen on a curved surface. You did not even make an attempt to support the reasons why it can only happen on a flat surface. Hence why your claim is unsupported. You simply make claims and demand they are correct. That is an unsupported claim.

Please refrain from commenting with your unsupported claims and unsupported accusations, as I've asked you to a dozen or more times now.

it can only happen if the sun is much closer than is said.

should the sun be millions of miles away all the rays would come thru straight.

you are not attempting to get at the truth. you aren't interested in discussion, please stop pretending you are.

I'm downvoting you again. YOu had a chance to make a substantiated claim SEVERAL TIMES and you refused. THEN after I ask you not to comment any more, you continue to do so with more unsupported claims.

You do not seem to understand the difference between a claim with evidence to back it up (a supported claim) and one in which you simply declare something to be true without any evidence (an unsupported claim).

Please refrain from commenting here when you do not understand the difference. Plus, again, this is science to falsify the unsupported claim.

Not sure why you would have a problem with that if you are looking for the truth. I guess you are not. Plus, I've already falsified it. I have several photos LIKE THE ONE IN THE POST. But I'd like to have more and better quality ones.

Don't downvote users expressing opinions you don't like. Ignore them and move on.

Congratulations @kerriknox! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of posts published

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

By upvoting this notification, you can help all Steemit users. Learn how here!

Awesome I ll try to come up with something good :*

Great. I look forward to seeing it.

My entry to this contest: https://steemit.com/reflection-challenge/@littleboy/light-reflection-on-curved-surface

To be honest, I am first participating in this contest, so I am not sure how it works. I hope my entry fulfills all the requirements. Please inform me if it doesn't.

Hi little boy, thank you for your entry, but it does not meet the requirements. It was supposed to be on a surface that you could measure or visibly see is curved in some way, and to also show an image that proves or shows how you determined the surface was curved.

While water IS curved, due to both tides and the curvature of the earth, you would have needed to include an image or video evidence of how you determined the curvature. I hope you try to enter again though. There is still time.

I thought that I had made it clear, but perhaps I didn't do such a great job explaining the contest.

Also, could you edit the post to remove the flatearth, and reflection-challenge tags?

Thanks, but it is not possible to change the primary tag. I removed the flatearth tag but the reflection-challenge tag can't be removed.

Did you mean curve like this?

Yeah! Something like that. Although, that looks like it's been photoshopped or is an animation. I want an actual image, one with a line of light to the observer.

Light and its nature have caused a lot of ink to flow during these last decades.

Dream as if you'll live forever. Live as if you'll die today. Have a nice day :)

This post received a 2.62% upvote from @randowhale thanks to @kerriknox! To learn more, check out @randowhale 101 - Everything You Need to Know!

This post has received a 16.32 % upvote from @buildawhale thanks to: @kerriknox. Send at least 0.50 SBD to @buildawhale with a post link in the memo field for a portion of the next vote.

To support our curation initiative, please vote on my owner, @themarkymark, as a Steem Witness

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.25
TRX 0.11
JST 0.032
BTC 62432.37
ETH 3003.22
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.78