Post Promotion applied after First Payout [Bug] - Affected accounts

in #post-promotion8 years ago (edited)

Some of you have experienced this bug on your own, some have been warned by @jesta posting about it (kudos @jesta!).
The bug has also been submitted by him to GitHub: https://github.com/steemit/steemit.com/issues/199 and a hot patch has been applied: https://github.com/steemit/steemit.com/pull/200

Still, some people lost SBD due to this issue while trying to promote their posts, 376.414 SBD to be exact.
With the much appreciated help of @lukestokes who provided me with a data dump on the promoted posts that are paid out, I was able to get a full list of authors who got their SBD burned without the post being actually promoted.

The person who aparently lost the most was @scott.stevens who tried 3 times to send SBD to the @null account but to no avail. The total amount he spent was 119 SBD.

Full table below, sorted by highest amounts burned:

UsernamePostPromo Amt.
scott.stevenswhat-happens-when-it-ends119
puhoshvillepopularscience-neural-networks-how-does-it-work-and-my-appeal-to-steemians31.026
inertiaradiator-steem-ruby-api-client30
thecryptofiendthe-steemit-etiquette-guide-illustrated-by-klye30
kendewittportal-into-the-multiverse-a-prelude-to-merwin-in-the-multiverse-original-recursive-science-fiction21
zaebarssee-you-at-sea-copengagen-or-a-sheer-misunderstanding15
galamirissagifs-siria-and-delawer-art10
begstreetsan-old-town-somewhere-along-the-adriatic-in-black-and-white10
jestawitness-thread-jesta10
condrafive-reasons-stranger-things-is-the-best-tv-show-of-20168
condradoes-steemit-need-a-share-button-and-other-questions7
blackeyedfinancial-freedom-with-ynab7
fyrstikkencrypto-land-a-comedy-by-fyrstikken6
albertfallsteemit-ceo-and-co-founder-ned-scott-just-shared-some-exciting-news-of-what-s-to-come5
albertfallshocking-facebook-changes-its-news-feed-algorithm-to-combat-clickbait5
blue1950obamacare-for-profit-insurers-and-the-luckless-people-under-them-another-outrage-brewing5
rwgundersongleaning-truth-in-media-tankman-and-the-tiananmen-square5
thebluepandabluepanda-goes-to-the-beach-a-photo-reportage3.067
augurcartoon-series3
nestorstablehello-steemit-i-d-like-to-introduce-myself-and-a-short-history-of-becoming-a-cooking-enthusiast3
deanliua-dear-wang-letter-how-i-miss-you-and-steemit2.101
deanliuwitnessing-the-journey-of-a-station2.02
uwe69bitcoin-vs-steem-feinde-oder-freunde2.01
cryptosjust-caught-that-one-whale-ing-around-what-do-you-think2.009
mikeherehow-to-draw-a-stick-figure-this-is-for-the-99-99-that-think-they-have-no-talent2
jenniferskylerhow-cancer-cannabis-an-original-comedy-tv-series-idea-by-jenniferskyler-with-love-from-portland2
nebcatconfessions-of-an-accidental-photographer2
nebcathello-steemit-deneb-catalan-portrait-photographer-in-pdx2
steemitcharitysteemitcharity-introduction-post-upvoting-for-good1.653
dahaz159future-concepts-explored-part-3-collective-consciousness-distributed-intelligence-and-the-identity-structures-of-super-organisms1.1
originateour-alien-megastructure-in-space-kic-8462852-the-most-mysterious-star-in-the-universe1.04
timclifflet-s-make-steemit-better-comprehensive-list-of-suggested-ui-ux-improvements-to-make-to-the-steemit-com-website1.03
condrabotanic-gardens-dublin-ireland-a-photographic-tour1.02
deanliua-story-of-a-homeless-mom-whales-casual-life-revealed1.01
deanliuwalk-into-the-island-s-night1.01
teamsteemy-steem-emoji-stickers-smiley1
jakosteemit-is-the-key-example-of-a-new-entrepreneurship-trend-which-rules-were-set-by-the-bitcoin-protocol1
comealonga-small-peak-into-water-and-how-words-effect-us1
goingpaperawkward-family-story-shorts-with-goingpaper1
norbuworld-heritage-on-wheels-the-darjeeling-himalayan-railway1
zeinre-jesta-re-bmann-re-jesta-update-on-the-steempress-theme-bounty-20160829t093247333z1
belkinsmurals-from-our-streets-last-epic-part1
cloveandcinnamonstreet-photography-on-one-of-the-top-10-beaches-in-the-world-jericoacoara-brazil1
acidsunmy-cthulhu-scetch1
boombasticmy-5-year-old-girl-s-first-computer-puzzle-game1
twinnerfinancial-freedom-lifelong-with-minimal-effort-introducing-the-permacryptofolio-system-a-public-trading-experiment-using-real1
neopatriarchbus-stop-a-short-comic-story1
sandziropriklyucheniya-sibirskogo-arkheologa-ili-raskopki-po-makedonski1
dave-hughesthe-chained-library1
driv3ntraveling-the-country-with-the-steem-logo-in-my-head-why-i-decided-to-become-a-walking-billboard0.902
virtasharesteemit-cheat-sheet-posting-like-a-pro-on-steemit0.656
dercocosteemitphotochallenge-basic-editing-is-allowed-simple-way-to-make-your-photos-look-nicer0.6
moh-rokibdecentralized-social-networks-comparing-steemit-synereo-decent-alexandria-yours-network-safe-network-zeronet0.47
bitminterhow-to-avoid-the-physical-hazards-of-steemit0.438
brindleswanforgotten-history-of-wearable-computing-a-steemit-exclusive0.38
deanliuwhat-are-the-captains-doing-during-the-steem-price-storm-my-sunday-investigation0.211
deanliu3-ways-to-keep-you-awake-while-watching-the-most-talked-about-interview-last-week0.202
timcliffalternate-steem-powers-evolution-of-steem-an-idea-for-supporting-multiple-independent-steem-based-communities0.13
condraphotoshoot-steff-the-charmaniac0.11
deanliuideal-voting-sea-world-exemplified-no-graphs-sorry0.101
deanliudailydialogue-beta-0110-auld-lang-syne0.101
deanliuhow-can-a-government-boost-low-fertility-rate-a-million-dollar-slogan-perhaps0.101
deanliuowo-one-week-off-initiative-brought-to-you-by-dailydialogue-beta-01010.101
deanliulive-to-the-fullest-steam-at-tokyo-night0.101
deanliuwe-are-here0.101
krystlethe-kingdom-of-valcanne-s-guide-to-keltorin-world-map-histories-and-people0.1
ausbitbankabracadabra-an-exploration-of-words-and-morphing-intent-downtherabbithole0.1
deanliublocks-chained-and-interwined0.1
ranko-kexcellent-free-images-you-can-use-on-your-steemit-post0.096
mashupeverything-you-need-to-know-to-start-meeting-more-women0.045
condrafly-my-uglies-macro-insects-with-off-camera-flash0.04
condraheadshot-photography-with-a-pop-up-studio0.03
condrared-things-from-countries-i-ve-never-been-to-featuring-somesockpuppet-as-author0.02
beanztraining-guide-dogs-for-the-blind-part-10.019
chhikarayour-steemit-account-has-been-suspended-reason-you-write-only-about-steemit0.014
dennygalindohelp-me-build-a-topic-feed0.01
alitasnew-steemit-ambassador-invites-you-to-a-city-tour-through-buenos-aires-argentina0.01
crypt0minechasing-the-world-record-in-overclocking-cpus-with-liquid-nitrogen0.01
twitteringwhat-could-possibly-beat-pokemon0.01
luisucv34the-necessary-rescue-of-venezuela-the-words-of-a-young-father-english-version-upvote-for-venezuela0.005
beanzgreetings-fellow-steemians-i-hope-the-oceans-not-as-cold-as-it-is-here-in-ireland-because-i-m-getting-in0.001
luisucv34synereo-alternative-to-steemit-what-do-you-think0.001
steemwelcomehello-steemians-i-m-steemwelcome0.001
krystlesteem-will-rise-the-steemit-anthem-new-video0.001

While doing the stats I looked at posts that were promoted and had their payout before the @steemitblog announcement of the Post Promotion feature (8/29/2016 21:58) which enabled the option and obviously, any post with its payout before the option was active experiences this issue by default.
I continued to analyze the list and have found a few more which I added to the table.
If your post didn't have its payout before the post promotion option became active or the Boost Payment is below 4 SDB, you may not be in the table above. Let me know in the comments if you're not on the list and should be.

Hopefully a compensation way will be found so that everybody is happy in the end.

Later Edit:
Everyone in the list above should now have a reimbursement in their wallets. @ned provided the budget to @zaebars who ensured the reimbursement distribution. For full transparency, Ned has also sent him and me 100SBD each as a reward for the initiative.
Me so happy to have helped make a difference. Steemit naysayers: eat you heart out! Steem(it) and the people behind it rock!


With this post I also want to start a personal initiative. I've decided that 10% of all my post earnings from now on will be directed to supporting community efforts, people and initiatives that I believe benefit Steemit and make it a better place.
For this post, 10% of its total author payout value (SBD+STEEM) will be transferred (as SBD equivalent) to the @robinhoodwhale as sponsorship.
Please consider sponsoring this cause yourself if you haven't done it already.

Robin Hood Whale (RHW) is the community's solution to an essential problem that plagues Steemit: how to get noticed and upvoted before you have a big enough following. Right now, if you are not upvoted by a “whale” account, it is very difficult to get exposure and any substantial rewards, which leads to many great authors leaving Steemit.
Robin Hood wants to be the “whale” that finds and helps a diverse set of talented, yet unrecognized authors. The proposed way of doing this is to cycle between different authors, upvoting ~10-20 quality posts daily. RHW won't upvote the same authors twice in any 10-day period in an effort to support more people and discourage any kind of abuse or ulterior motives.
For RHW to have any meaningful impact, it must reach whale-status of SP and/or many bot followers. Yet, this is just the tip of the iceberg for this initiative. As featured authors and posts will be publicly announced periodically, we hope to inspire a movement that will lead to authors gaining fans, following and eventually to be able to self-sustain a blog on SteemIT without the RHW help at all.
In a way, RHW's ultimate goal would be to not be needed at all. But as new enthusiastic authors join, RHW will be here to find them, help them and upvote them, growing the community and the overall quality of what you can find on Steemit.

Sort:  

As an update on this for anyone reading:
Everyone in the list above should now have a reimbursement in their wallets thanks to @ned, with the help of @zaebars and based on the list above.
How cool is this? Mesa so happy to have helped make a difference. Steemit naysayers: eat you heart out!

Great post and great work @anduweb! I love the RHW support initiative as well. Following.

Couldn't have done it without the data from you! Thank you for your support!

Thank you I appreciate your efforts to get mine and everyones money back!

Thanks, anytime!

What a great initiative! As a dev, any way to get involved

Thank you! It is sorted for the moment as all the accounts in the list have been reimbursed. If there is anyone who should have been and wasn't, we welcome their comment.

I see myself on the list, I was too eager to try out the new feature before @jesta posted about the bug, so it was too late to do anything... 2 SBD burned.

who knows, maybe they will be returned.

Same here. Lucky I didn't spend too much, and was mainly trying it out to explore the new feature. I considered it a loss chalked up to "beta". Thanks a lot for putting this together! I was curious who else was affected; plus if they decide to do a refund, you've done a lot of the hard work for them 😀

Thank you for saying that! Since they have a lot on their plate right now I thought it would be nice if we can help and lend a hand. Hopefully it gets noticed and actioned upon for the larger payments at least.

Sh.t is it my fold? :)

can you extrapolate?

.

oh OK, it's clear now. Nah, I don't think it's your fault man, bugs happen but I'm happy we sorted it out :)

you are a hero!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.16
JST 0.030
BTC 65754.91
ETH 2670.18
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.88