You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Ned Scott and @theoretical of Steemit Explore Oracles on Steem

in #ned6 years ago

a superlinear rewards curve creates a strong incentive for those who have a large amount of STEEM to self-vote and collude

Isn't it exactly the opposite way? Linear curve incentivizes self-voting, that's why it is now so frequent...

Sort:  



That should help clarify it ;-)

Superlinear is not the same as linear.

How about explaining what Superlinear is. Because it's the first time I hear the word. And the word makes no sense as you can improve on linear. Something which is linear can't be made more linear. Either you are linear or you are not.

Plot me a graph so I understand it.

We have a linear curve now and we have much self-voting and upvote-bot-using now. When we had a superlinear curve there wasn't as much self-voting as now. I think that's what @hr1 is meaning.

Ah, I see. The distinction is between superlinear rewards based on stake and superlinear rewards based on individuality. Superlinear rewards distributed based on individuality is a fundamentally different thing. As was explained in the post, with superlinear rewards distributed based on individuality, a self-vote gets you nothing more than a vote for someone else because your stake is irrelevant. All that matters in such a case is whether the thing you vote on receives more upvotes in the future from many more individuals regardless of their stake.

Now I see:

You call exponential growth superlinear. That's very confusing. Why not use words people understand?

And the opposite of what is needed. Inverse exponential rewards – sublinear as you would call it - is needed to help plankton accounts along:

And would reflect real live articles better. Articles don't become exponentially better. Quite the opposite they get closer and closer to perfect without reaching it.

Linear is proportional to n (which is the same as n^1). The exponential (a^n) is not the only superlinear curve, you can have n^2, n^3, ...

hello @hr1 could you take a look at this request from my project? I'm sorry I sent it over here, but I don't know where to reach you.

https://steemit.com/delegate/@mayvil/delegate-sp-with-steemconnect-and-what-benefit-you-get

"superlinear": f = a*x^y, y >= 2, but y can be a real number.

Thank you @hr1 for upvoting my post,

@hr1 resteem and upvote my post

Gracias por tu voto, ;-)
Thanks for your vote, ;-)
Merci pour votre vote, ;-)

hello mate @ hr1 could communicate with us to the discord

That's what I observed as well!

I need to talk with you @hr1...you use discord or steemit.chat?

Estoy completamente deacuerdo con @hr1

Please stop upvoting my posts.
OK I don't need your upvotes.. You're annoying-
Thanks

HR1 Please stop upvoting my posts.
OK I don't need your upvotes.. You're annoying-
Thanks

@hr1, Please UpVote and resteem my next post. It's nothing magic but it's fine. I am extremely low on Steem unlike you Darling. Thank you.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.29
TRX 0.11
JST 0.033
BTC 63458.69
ETH 3084.37
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.99