一张图片引发的一些争论和思考

in #cn-reader8 years ago (edited)

  下午要去香港参加 “EOS.IO Hong Kong Meet-Up”,我早上较早就起床了,看了下手机,发现微信评委群里,评委们在讨论一幅作品,有评委表示看不懂但做了推荐,也有评委写了评语并推荐,当然,也有评委明确表示反对。


  姑且先不讨论作品的内容。根据我个人的习惯,一般情况下,我是不太介入到具体的作品推荐评论中,原因有二,一是因为我们有评委组和各位无论是实力或者是责任心,都是让我很信的过的评委老师们;二来如果我过早地发表了自己的看法,难免会让人觉得先入为主,不好再提出其它尤其是不同意见,或者说碍于给我情面却又不太好公开反驳,这一点是我不想看到,也不想要的结果。


  如果碰到非常优秀的作品,我还是会忍不住在评委群里吆喝那么几嗓子的,毕竟,我也是喜欢写作的,可能是所好略同吧,读到自己喜欢的作品,会让自己发自内心的心情愉悦,即便是自己给自己定了尽量不参与评判的约法三章等,但仍是偶尔也忍不住,这种感受,我自己对自己都表示可以理解。


  当然,如果以个人的角度来看,我还是想说下自己的看法。


  我做事有个自己的准则,就是看不懂的东西不做太多评论,但是我也反对一些将简单的内容复杂化,尤其是夸张化。扯远一些,相信每一个喜欢文学的同学,对鲁迅的文章一定不会陌生。我读书的时候,对于鲁迅的文章,不能算特别喜欢,但也谈不上讨厌,说再准确些,我喜欢他文章的一些大白话,一些话语说的很通俗,如同邻家兄长在跟你在对面神侃般。但我也有点不太喜欢他的文章,准确地说我是不喜欢过多地解读他文章的内容,比如鲁迅先生说过,这世上本来没有路,走的人多,自然就有了。


  这个只是一句很普通的话,但我在上学的时候,不但为此“被迫”挖空心思解读这背后隐藏的更深的道理,同时还将这句连同那句话所在的那段落文章都要背诵下来,时隔多年后,我依然想不通“走的人多了,自然就有了”到底跟革命、跟做人有什么关系?


  因此,我的看法是,如果你真的喜欢并看明白了,我支持你,不用顾及太多去推荐吧;如果你也跟我一般看不明白,那就放弃也可以不用做任何评论;如果你明确反对,因为你不认可,我也同样支持你,更欣赏你敢于说出那句“皇帝并没有穿什么衣服呀”的勇气。

  每个人所处角色虽不同,但各自都有自己的权利。

  

Sort:  

English Version On Today's Article

Title: Some pictures sparked some debates and reflections. 

Afternoon going to Hong Kong to participate in the EOS party, I got up early in the morning, looked under the mobile WeChat, found that "Yue Dan evaluation committee group", the judges were discussing a work, some judges said they did not understand but made recommendations There are also judges who have written reviews and recommended them. Of course, some judges have expressed their opposition.

Let's not discuss the content of the work first. According to my personal habits, under normal circumstances, I'm not very involved in the specific recommendations for works. There are bright spots. First, because we have judges and everyone, regardless of their strength or sense of responsibility, they make me believe. If I express my opinion prematurely, it will inevitably make the judges feel that I have already confirmed my opinion. I'm not good at making other, especially disagreements. This is the result that I do not want to see or want.

If I come across very good works, I will not be able to endure a few critics in the judges group. After all, I also like to write. It may be better to read it. If I read my favorite work, I will make myself. Feeling happy from the bottom of my heart, even if I set myself up for the third chapter of the covenant that I didn't participate in judging as much as possible, but I still can't help but sigh. I feel like I understand myself.

Of course, if you look from a personal point of view, I still want to say my own opinion.

I have my own criteria for doing things, that is, I don't comment too much on things I don't understand, but I also oppose some of the simple things that are complicated, especially exaggerated. Pulling away a bit, I believe that every student who likes literature will be familiar with Lu Xun's article. When I was studying, I was not particularly fond of Lu Xun’s articles, but I couldn’t talk about them. I was more accurate. I liked some of the great vernacular in his articles. Some of the words were very popular, if the neighbor’s brother was giving you Read an article. But I also don't like his article a bit. To be exact, I don't like to read too much about the content of his article. For example, Mr. Lu Xun said that there is no way in the world and many people will naturally follow.

This is just a very common sentence, but when I was in school, I was not only forced to interpret this deeper truth hidden behind it, but also memorized the sentence along with the passage where the sentence was written. After many years, I still can't figure out how many people walked, naturally there is. What is the relationship with the revolution and the people?

Therefore, my opinion is that if you really like it and understand it, I support you and don’t care too much about recommending it; if you don’t understand it with me, then there’s no need to comment; if you’re against I also support you.

Each person has different roles, but each has his own rights. 

This

This article written by my dearest friend @rivalhw ✍ 

Thanks my friend for your kind of words and writing such a good post really I appreciate you I hope you will be written those type of content in future. best of luck my friend and best wishes for you! 

Loading...

还有另一种看法:放松后大家尽情各抒己见而又不因争论不开心

难为你们不辞辛苦,没有报酬地鼓励这些创作者。

什么图发生来看看就知道了,很好奇啊,让大家看看就都知道了

无关理性与感性,评判可以没有准则,但是要坚守底线

@rivalhw, 有品位!

@rivalhw, steemit上我觉得只需要静静读你的贴就值了~~~ img

可见做评委不简单呀,一来每个人的眼光不一样,看文章的也不一样。对我一个汉语学习者而言,看看评委选的文章,就相当于老师在文章上评分,要这样写,那样描述,才算是个品质好的中文文章。
但最后,我能学到东西,读得明白,就好啦

是的,做评委们不容易

我只记得初中时凡是鲁迅先生的课文,书中的空白地方都不够用。

过多诠释,反而是偏离本意了

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.04
TRX 0.32
JST 0.078
BTC 63982.50
ETH 1670.37
USDT 1.00
SBD 0.41