Bringing Yellow Back - Why I'm Ditching Racially Specific Emojis

yellow_blue_emojis.jpg

Earlier this year a relative sent me a Whatsapp message, the message in itself was nothing special, however at the end he gave me a thumbs up emoji.

It wasn't the fact that he left me a thumbs up that caught my attention, it was the fact that the

thumb was racially accurate. He has quite dark chocolate brown skin, and his emoji matched that.

Having not realised that the emoji palette had been upgraded, I'd just been using the good old Simpsons yellow, I was reasonably intrigued at this new development.

Over the next few months we spoke quite a lot over Whatsapp, each time I sent my yellow emoji, he would respond with his racially accurate one. Until finally I started to respond in kind.

However something I couldn't quite articulate was nagging at the back of my mind. Racially specific emojis were wrong, I just didn't know why.

Mirror Mirror

Once the genie was out of the bottle I couldn't just restrict sending my racially accurate emoji to my relative, that felt kind of weird. It was all or nothing.

I remember sending my light brown thumbs up to a friend of mine, and he responded with his Caucasian one in return.

Soon I was using my racially accurate emojis to all my friends, and they were responding back with theirs as well.

Before long, within my circle of friends and family it became normal to represent your skin tone when sending a hand gesture emoji. Be it a thumbs up, fist bump, or clap hands, I found myself on more than one occasion wondering if the emoji I was about to send was a fair representation of my exact skin colour.

However the undefined thought that was gnawing away at the edge of my conscious mind, refused to go away. I knew there was something wrong with the skin tone emojis, yet I couldn't quite articulate why.

Then finally yesterday, it dawned on me . . .

Emoji Utility

I've spoken in the past about the importance of emojis. Whilst they may seem trivial at first glance, they are actually an extremely important part of the fine and complex lattice that is human social interaction.

In the past when we regularly wrote letters to each other, there was perhaps no need for the humble emoji. Sure enough if you had asked me at any time in the 1980s if I had seen the latest emoji, I would have smiled, nodded and backed away slowly from you, whilst all the time keeping eye contact.

The reason we didn't need them when we wrote letters, was because there were no real or imagined boundaries set around their potential length.

We could be as expressive as we wanted, with our words, and we didn't have the sword of immediacy hanging over our heads. Indeed a person might take several days or even weeks to craft a letter, before finally sending it on to its destination.

In those scenarios, you made sure that the exact emotions you were attempting to convey to the recipient of your letter, made it onto the page in no unmistakable terms.

*Dear Fiona,

I was very disappointed to hear . . .*

Fast forward to the present day where most people do not send letters anymore, and messages to Santa aside many youngsters having never sent a letter to anyone (my eight year old sent her first one yesterday).

Today we send text and email, which by their very nature are short. When mobile phones were first able to send SMS messages, you were restricted in how much you could say. Over a certain amount and the text would divide itself up and send over two or more messages to your recipient.

The mobile networks weren't as whizz bang fast as they are today, and it wasn't unheard of to receive the second half of a text several hours, or even days after the first.

Even though that is no longer the case, the actual act of sending a text message is laborious, and the average concentration span has rapidly decreased. With just a few words and lines to play with to get your message across, it is nigh on impossible to convey your emotions as well.

Enter the emoji as our champion. Now a simple smiley face, thumbs up, or angry emoji can smartly and efficiently add emotion to our words. Leaving us safe in the knowledge that our message will not be misconstrued by the one who receives it.

What Colour Is Emotion?

That is the kind of question that might have been asked of you at a beatnik party in the 1960s (I don't know, coz I wasn't there man), however it makes absolutely no sense to try and give emotion a colour.

The reason we have more muscles in our face, and more expressive gestures than any other creature on earth, is because of our complex social structures. Which in turn have contributed to us living in such large groups, in relative harmony.

When two dogs meet each other on the street, they rely on the smell of their genitals and the tempo of their tail wags in order to gauge each other's mood. Even then they get it wrong, my dog cannot tell the difference between a dog that wants to play with him and one that wants to fight. Therefore he treats all dogs with caution.

In fact dogs can read human emotions better than they can each other's . . .

Whereas if I on the other hand, travel to Pakistan, China, Russia, Eritrea, or any other country where I can't speak the language, I can still read a smile or a scowl in the same way. In fact you can test this by taking an online test whereby you read emotions of different people of all races just by looking at the eyes.

Emotions are important to us, and they are universal. An angry Chinese man looks the same as an angry Nigerian or American.

It's not just restricted to our faces either, the world over, the 'hands up' gesture, whilst showing the palms, is used to placate a potentially volatile situation. Showing its recipient that you bare them no malice whatsoever.

In other words, emotion has no colour.

The Genius Of Yellow

Whoever decided to make the first colour emojis yellow, was either a social genius, or had simply subconsciously understood the racial neutrality of emotion.

In the same way you can't mistake the Simpsons for a real family, because unless a person is jaundiced, nobody real is that shade of yellow. So too do yellow emojis divorce themselves from any particular racial group.

Add to that, the fact that if I am conversing with you over Whatsapp, we are already fully aware of each other's ethnicity. Why then should we have to reinforce that with emojis?

Of course we don't, because by doing so, it is almost as if we are saying that my milk chocolate thumbs up, carries a different sentiment than your pinky-white one. When in fact we know the opposite to be true.

Back To Neutrality

So yesterday, I switched back to good old yellow. I sent a yellow thumbs up to the same friend I'd sent a brown one to before, I could almost hear his sigh of relief as he sent a yellow one back.

And once more, there was balance in the universe.

My emotions, as with yours, have no race, therefore if my emoji is going to accurately reflect your real life emotions, they should be racially neutral.

Long live the yellow emoji!



emojis_in_a_row.jpg

Images: Pixabay Creative Commons

WHAT ABOUT YOU GUYS, WERE YOU AWARE OF RACIALLY SPECIFIC EMOJIS? HAVE YOU BEEN USING THEM? HAVE PEOPLE SENT YOU THEM? DO YOU FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE WHEN SENDING OR RECEIVING THEM?

AS EVER, LET ME KNOW BELOW!

Cryptogee

Sort:  

I came to realize a few years ago how we often refer to 'skin tone' and imply that being a salmon-like pinkish colour. For example, foundation for a woman's skin is in the lighter colour range called 'skin tone' and in the darker colour range 'dark brown' - as if the latter isn't 'skin tone'.

Just a short introduction as there's so much more to it, to explain why when I saw 'skin toned' smileys I was initially happy: I was sure this was a good thing! Finally people with non-light skin tones could express themselves in their own skin colour! Which was needed right? The era where 'skin tone' was only 'light' was over... I thought. And indeed, I saw some of my colleagues sending thumbs up in a dark brown shade.

Then I started to think if I wanted to change my emoticon colour. The first time I thought I'd do this was when my black colleague send me the darkest available thumbs up and I felt hesitant using the white one - suddenly I felt super aware of my skin colour, and it didn't feel right to sort of emphasize I had that white skin colour against his dark one. (Especially since we've talked a lot about how his skin colour has played a huge (not positive) role in his life.)

I remember I hovered over the thumbs up I wanted to send back, trying to think which shade of light skin was 'mine', and in the end I felt so uncomfortable with picking those 'white' smileys I simply picked the standard, neutral, yellow one.

And I haven't changed that since.

Interesting topic to say the least. It's one of those things where you know 'they meant well' but the effect is the opposite. I can only imagine how happy certain groups of people are they can pick that white-skinned emoji...

I totally get it! Especially you hovering over the button, I was the same, but I gave in and went for the racially specific one.

I think like you say, they 'meant well', perhaps because the yellow in the Simpsons, is actually meant to be white, otherwise everyone would be yellow.

However our emotions don't need colour, they are universal, so until something better comes along, let's stick to yellow :-) 😜💪🤓😁

Cg

Well I have been using it especially for thumbs-up, claps and fist bumps. The one I use us actually darker than my skin colour. I use it because I like the colour. Yellow seems to ordinary.

Yeah I know what you mean, however emotions are not racially specific, which is why it felt weird to me. My emotions are neutral, so I'm going to back to yellow. 👍💪😜

Cg

What an excellent post to get my brain in motion on this dragging Monday morning! Though I have not yet run into this situation, you have saved me the trouble of traveling the same path to get to the inevitable conclusion- #teamneutralemojis!

Beautifully written, so incredibly true about letters pre-internet. I don't know how I've missed you along the steemit journey, but glad to find you now! Hmm, now what emoji should I go with...👏😁

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

Never heard of them, but there is always old school :)

It's funny, because on Steemit I often use the old school (ASIICs) :-)

:-( :-D and so on...

However if you do that in facebook, it instantly converts them (to yellow emojis).

Cg

Which begs the question...why do the 'left' get so upset about gray...mmmm...lol

hey @cryptogee! I enjoyed reading your post and get to know more about how you think.

In my case, when I first saw the different color emojis, my first reaction was... why? Then I noticed it that most of my friends or maybe all of them did not care really.

Have I use the exact emoji that represents the color of my skin, nope! I actually started to use the black one, then the other colors, whatever I felt in the moment lol. Now that I think about it... I had no specific intention, I just wanted to use them all. Maybe it is because I come from a country, where we really don't care colors of skin, at least the majority of people here are like that. Panama is like a melting pot from the beginnings.

Although, I personally think there is no need to make sure what type of skin color you are by using an emoji. But if people feel comfortable about it, then it's ok as well.

It's definitely a good topic that make you think about it.

Take care my Steemit bro!

Peace and Love for everybody!

Haha, I like that! Maybe I'll start using varying types :-) Thanks for dropping by, I've been a bit quiet lately, time to Steem it up again :-)

Cg

Loading...

Ha, I love this, very good explanation. I hated it when they introduced the racially specific emojis because I felt we don't need them. Although I do admit I sometimes use them just because that jaundiced yellow feels awfully off-putting :))

Posted using Partiko Android

Ah you see, I was explaining this just last night to a friend of mine. To our generation that yellow is the colour of the Acid House movement, which in turn is associated with loud dance music and drugs.

However I was explaining that to the average 20 year old, it's just yellow. 🤣😂🤣🤓

Cg

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.35
TRX 0.12
JST 0.040
BTC 70797.92
ETH 3553.00
USDT 1.00
SBD 4.76